CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM Doc lap - Tir do - Hanh phuc

Can Tho, ngay 25 thang 06 nam 2024.

QUYET DINH CHAP NHAN VIEC KHANG C AO QUA HAN TOA AN NHAN DAN THANH PHO C AN THO

Vol Hoi dong xet khang cao qua lian gom cd:

ong Lam Thanh Them- Kiem sat vien.

Sau khi xet xu so tham. ngay 24 thang 04 nam 2024 bi don Cong ty L co don khang cao vdi noi dung khong dong y ban an so tham cua Toa an nhan dan quan Ninh Kieu.

XET THAY:

Ngay 10/04//2024. Toa an nhan dan quan Ninh Kieu xet xu vu an tranh chap dan su giua nguyen don ong Le Thanh M vdi bi don Cong ty TNHH L (goi tat la Cong ty L). Den ngay 24/04/2024. bi don co don khang cao. Ngay 26/04/2024. Toa an nhan dan quan Ninh Kieu ban hanh Giay xac nlian da nhan don khang cao va ra Thong bao nop tien tam ung an phi phuc tham doi bi don khang cao la Cong ty L. Thong bao duoc giii den dia chi cua cong ty va duoc tong dat qua dich vu buu chinh. Ngay 02/5/2024. dich vu buu chinli bao phat da thuc hien tong dat thanh cong vao ngay 28/4/2024 (ngudi ky nlian ten H).

Theo bi don thi ngay 02/5/2024. bi don moi nlian duoc Thong bao nop tam tmg an phi phuc tham tu cua hang giat ui T (phia trudc Cong ty). Ngay 10/5/2024. bi don den nop tam ung an phi tai Chi cue Thi hanh an quan Ninh Kieu thi Chi cue Thi hanh an khong giai quyet vi Thong bao da het han 10 ngay. de nghi duong su den toa xin thong bao kliac. Bi don den Toa an quan N xin thong bao khac thi toa an cung khong giai quyet va yeu cau lam giai trinh khang cao. Ngay 14/5/2024. bi don nop Van ban trinh bay y kien ve viec khang cao.

Theo quy dinli tai diem c klioan 4 Dieu 274 Bo luat to tung dan su thi Toa an tra lai don khang cao neu thuoc trudng hop tai klioan 2 Dieu 276 Bo luat to tung dan su.

Klioan 2 Dieu 276 quy dinh: Trong thdi han 10 ngay, ke tu ngay nhan dupe thong bao etia Toa an ve viec nop tien tam ung an phi phuc tham, ngudi khang cao phdi nop tien tam ung an phi phuc tham va nop cho Toa an cap so tham bien lai thu tien tarn img an phi phuc tham. Het thoi han nay ma ngitdi khang cdo khong nop tien tam img an phi phuc tham thi dupe coi Id tit bd viec khang cdo, trit trudng hop co ly do chinh dang.

Toa an cap so tham cho rang ngubi khang cao khong nop tien tam ung an phi phuc tham trong thoi gian quy dinli nhung khong cd thong bao tra lai don khang cao nen khong xac dinli duoc ngay ngubi khang cao nlian duoc thong bao nop tien tam ling an phi phuc tham, cung nliu ngay ket thuc viec nop tam ung an phi phuc tham, can chap nlian lbi trinli bay cua ngubi khang cao. Bbi con co cac ly do sau:

Tai Dieu 178 Bo luat to tung dan su quy dinh ve: Thu tuc cap, tong dat, thong bao true tiep cho co quan, to chuc

“Trudng hop ngitdi dirge cap, tong dat, thong bdo Id co quan, to chuc thi van bdn to tung phdi dupe giao trite tiep cho ngitdi dqi dien theo phdp luat hoqc nguai chiu trach nhiem nhan van bdn ciia co quan, to chitc do vd phdi dupe nhung ngitdi nay' ky nhan. Truong hop co quan, to chitc dupe cap, tong dat, thong bdo cd ngitdi dqi dien tham gia to tung hoac cit ngitdi dai dien nhan van bdn to tung thi nhimg ngitdi nay' ky nhan van bdn to tung do. Ngay ky nhan la ngay dupe cap, tong dat, thong bdo”.

Cong ty L co uy quyen cho ca nlian tham gia to tung, nlian cac van ban to tung... nhimg cap so tham lai tong dat true tiep cho Cong ty, ngubi ky nlian van ban khong xac dinli duoc co tham quyen nlian van ban hay khong.

Nliu vay, viec ngubi khang cao khong dong duoc tam ung an phi phuc tham dung thoi han da thong bao duoc xem la trb ngai kliach quan.

Quan diem cua dai dien Vien kiem sat nhan dan thanli pho Can Tho ve viec chap nlian khang cao qua han cua bi don la phu hop vbi quan diem cua Hoi dong xet khang cao qua han nen duoc chap nlian.

Can cu vao Dieu 275 cua Bo luat to tung dan sir;

QUYET DINH:

• 1. Chap nhan viec khang cao qua han cua bi don doi vbi Ban an dan su so tham so 77/2024/DS-ST ngay 25/04/2024 cua Toa an nlian dan quan Ninli Kieu, thanli pho Can Tho ve viec: tranh chap hop dong thi cong.

• 2. Toa an cap so tham co trach nhiem tien hanli cac thu tuc do Bo luat to tung dan su quy dinh.

  Not nlian:

  • - TAND Q. Ninh Kieu

  • - VKSND TP.Can Tho:

  -Cac duong su:

  • - Luu ho so vu an.

TM. HOI DONG XET KHANG CAO QUA HAN THAM PHAN - CHU TOA PHIEN HOP