CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM Doc lap - Ta do - Hanh phuc

Ban an so: 75/2024/HNGD-ST Ngay: 09 - 4 - 2024

V/v: “Tranh chap khong cong nhan quan lie vo chong, tranh chap nudicon”

NHAN DANH

NtfOC CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM • • •

TOA AN NHAN DAN QUAN 5, THANH PHO HO CHI MINH

- Thanh ph an Hoi dong xet xic so’ th am gom co:

Tham phan - Chu toci phien tda: Ba Do Thi Ngoc Bich Cac Hoi tham nhan dan:

• 1. Ong Pham Duy Bao

• 2. Ba Tran Nguyet Mai

- T/ur ky phien tda: Ba Cao Nguyen Thien Kim- Thu ky Tda an nhan dan Quan 5.

- Dai dien Vien kiem sat nhan dan Quan 5: Ba Tran Thi Hong Phuong -

Kiem sat vien.

Trong ngay 09 thang 4 nam 2024 tai tru so Tda an nhan dan Quan 5, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh xet xu so tham cong khai vu an lion nhan gia dinh thu ly so: 67/2024/TLST-HNGD ngay 25 thang 3 nam 2024, ve viec: “Tranh chap khong cong nhan quan he vo chong, tranh chap nudi con” theo Quyet dinh dua vu an ra xet xu so: 43/2024/QDXXST-HNGD ngay 01 thang 4 nam 2024, giua cac duong su:

Nguyen dan: Ba Huynh Thi Hong N, sinh nam 1980 (Xin vang mat) Dia chi thudng tru: chung cu L, khu B, dudng so B, phudng A, quan B, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh

Tam tru: 6 B, Phudng N, Quan N, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh

Bi dan: Ong Nguyen Ngoc T, sinh nam 1981 (Xin vang mat) Dia chi: 1 H, Phudng C, Quan E, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh

NOI DUNG VU AN:

• •

• * Trong dan khai kien ngay 08 thang 3 nam 2024, 02 ban tu khai ngay 01 thang 4 nam 2024 va trong qua trinh to tung nguven dan — ba Huynh Thi Hong N trinh bay:

Ba N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T tu nguyen tim hieu va chung song nhu vo chong tu dau nam 2019 nhung khong dang ky ket hon. Qua trinh chung song, ba N va ong T co vdi nhau 01 ngudi con chung ten Nguyen Minh D (gidi tinh nam), sinh ngay 18/01/2022. Ba N va ong T co tien hanh lam giay khai sinh cho be Nguyen Minh D tai Uy ban nhan dan phudng A, quan B theo Giay khai sinh so 65/GKS-BS ngay 10/02/2022. Qua trinh chung song, vo chong co qua nhieu mau 9                         r                                                           x        x                     r

thuan khong the giai quyet duoc, doi ben da nhieu lan han gan tinh cam nhung khong co ket qua, mau thuan vo chong ngay cang nghiem trong. Nay nhan thay giua vo chong da khong con su ton trong lan nhau, tinh cam cung vi the ma khong 9                 F                                                x                r

the han gan duoc nen ba N de nghi Toa an giai quyet khong cong nhan quan he vo chong giua ba N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T de ba N on dinh cuoc song.

Ve van de con chung: Ba N va ong T co vdi nhau mot ngudi con chung la tre Nguyen Minh D (gidi tinh nam), sinh ngay 18/01/2022. Ba N yeu cau duoc true tiep nudi con chung. Ba N yeu cau ong Nguyen Ngoc T cap dudng nudi con chung moi thang 4.000.000 dong (bon trieu dong), bat dau thuc hien cap dudng vao ngay 01 den ngay 05 duong lich hang thang bat dau tu thang 5 nam 2024 den khi con 9                                                  <                                r

chung du 18 tuoi hoac co can cu cham dut viec cap dudng nudi con theo quy dinh phap luat. Viec giao nhan tien cap dudng se do ba N va ong T tu thuc hien hoac tai co quan thi hanh an dan su cd tham quyen. Truong hop han chot thdi han cap -w                                         9                                                                     r

dudng roi vao ngay nghi, ngay le ma khong the thuc hien duoc viec cap dudng thi viec cap dudng se duoc thuc hien vao ngay ngay lam viec tiep theo sau do.

Ve tan san chung va no chung: Ba N tu khai giua ba va ong T khong co tai san chung nen khong yeu cau Toa an giai quyet.

• * Tai Ta tu khai ngay 01 thang 4 nam 2024, bi dan — ong Nguyen Ngoc T trinh bay:

• - Ve quan he lion nhan: Ong T dong y viec Toa an khong cong nhan quan he

y                                                         ___ '                                        ___ '

vo chong giua ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong T vi hien nay vo chong khong the han gan duoc tinh cam.

• - Ve con chung: Ong Nguyen Ngoc T xac dinh giua ong T va ba N cd 01

(mot) ngudi con chung ten Nguyen Minh D (gidi tinh nam), sinh ngay 18/01/2022. sx      r     r

Ong T va ba N cd tien hanh lam giay khai sinh cho be Nguyen Minh D tai Uy ban nhan dan phudng A, quan B theo Giay khai sinh so 65/GKS-BS ngay 10/02/2022.

y                                                                                                <                                                              y

Ong T dong y giao con cho ba N true tiep nudi dudng. Ong T dong y cap dudng nudi con chung 4.000.000 dong (Bon trieu dong) mot thang. Ong T se thuc hien cap dudng vao ngay 01 den ngay 05 duong lich hang thang bat dau thuc hien tu thang 5 nam 2024 den khi con chung du 18 tuoi hoac co can cu chain dut viec cap dudng nudi con theo quy dinh phap luat. Viec giao nhan tien cap dudng se do ong

va ba N tu thirc hien hoac tai co quan thi hanh an dan sir co tham quyen. Truong hop han chot thoi han cap dubng roi vao ngay nghi, ngay le ma khong the thirc hien diroc viec cap dirong thi viec cap dirong se duoc thirc hien vao ngay ngay lam viec tiep theo sau do.

- Ve tai san chung va no chung: Ong Nguyen Ngoc T tu khai khong co, khong yeu cau Toa an giai quyet.

Tai phien toa:

Ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T deu co don xin xet xir vang mat.

Dai dien Vien kiem sat nhan dan Quan 5 phat bieu y kien:

Ve viec chap hanh phap luat to tung: Viec tuan theo phap luat td tung cua Tham phan, Hoi dong xet xir, Thu ky phien toa trong qua trinh giai quyet vu an. 9                                                           r                                                                   r                          •>                            r         \

Qua kiem sat viec giai quyet vu an tir khi thu ly den thoi diem nay thay rang Tham phan da chap hanh dung quy dinh tai Dieu 48 Bo luat To tung Dan sir. Tai phien toa, Hoi dong xet xu da tuan theo dung cac quy dinh cua Bo luat To tung Dan sir \                                9

ve xet xu so tham vu an.

Ve noi dung vu an: Can cu vao cac tai lieu, chung cir co trong ho so vu an, can cir trinh bay cua cac dirong sir trong qua trinh to tung, de nghi Hoi dong xet xu: Ve quan he lion nhan: Chap nhan yeu cau cua nguyen don la ba Huynh Thi Hong N, khong cong nhan quan he vo chong giua ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T. Ve con chung: Ba N va ong T co vdi nhau 01 ngubi con chung ten Nguyen Minh D (gibi tinh nam), sinh ngay 18/01/2022. Ba N va ong T co tien <                                                                                                         __ 9

hanh lam giay khai sinh cho be Nguyen Minh D tai Uy ban nhan dan phirbng A, quan B theo Giay khai sinh so 65/GKS-BS ngay 10/02/2022. Theo sir thoa thuan cua cac duong sir ve van de con chung thi de nghi Hoi dong xet xir giao tre Nguyen Minh D cho ba Huynh Thi Hong N true tiep chain soc, nuoi dirong; Ong T co z                                                                                                \                r                       \

nghia vu cap dubng nuoi con chung 4.000.000 dong (Bon trieu dong) mot thang vao ngay 01 den ngay 05 dirong lich hang thang, bat dau thirc hien tir thang 5 nam r                                                                              •>                                                             r                                       r

2024 den khi con chung dii 18 tuoi hoac co can cu chain dirt viec cap dubng nuoi con theo quy dinh phap luat. Ve tai san chung va no chung: Doi ben tir khai khong co nen de nghi Hoi dong xet xir khong xem xet. Ve an phi: Nguyen don la ba Huynh Thi Hong N chiu an phi hon nhan gia dinh so tham doi vbi tranh chap yr    r

khong cong nhan quan he vo chong. An phi cap dubng nuoi con chung ong Nguyen Ngoc T phai chiu theo quy dinh phap luat.

NHAN DINH CUA TOA AN:

• •

Tren co sb noi dung vu an, can cir vao cac tai lieu trong ho so vu an da diroc tham tra tai phien toa, Hoi dong xet xir nhan dinh:

• [1] Ve quan he tranh chap va tham quyen giai quyet vu an:

Ba Huynh Thi Hong N khbi kien yeu cau khong cong nhan quan he vo chong va yeu cau duoc true tiep nuoi dubng con vbi ong Nguyen Ngoc T, do do

3

r      /yr

quan he tranh chap thuoc linh virc hon nhan gia dinh. Ong Teo dia chi tai so A dudng H, Phuong C, Quan E, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh. Do vay, vu an thuoc tham quyen giai quyet ciia Toa an nhan dan Quan 5, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh can cir theo khoan 1 Dieu 28, diem a khoan 1 Dieu 35, Dieu 36, diem a khoan 1 Dieu 39 Bo luat To tung Dan sir.

yr

• [2] Ve sir vang mat cua dirong sir:

Nguyen don - ba Huynh Thi Hong N va bi don - ong Nguyen Ngoc T deu co don xin xet xir vang mat de ngay 01 thang 4 nam 2024. Do vay, Hoi dong xet xir **          r                                          r                                                ___ i                          9

van tien hanh xet xu vang mat ba N, ong T theo quy dinh tai diem a va diem b khoan 2 Dieu 227 Bo luat To tung dan sir.

• [3] Ve noi dung vu an: Doi vdi yeu cau khdi kien cua nguyen don - ba Huynh Thi Hong N, Hoi dong xet xu nhan thay:

  • [3.1] Ve quan he hon nhan: Viec ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T song chung vdi nhau nlnr vo chong nhung khong thirc hien cac quy dinh phap luat ve dang ky ket hon theo Luat hon nhan va gia dinh tai co quan chuc nang la vi pham phap luat hon nhan gia dinh. Ba N cung dong thuan ve viec khong cong nhan quan he vo chong nen Hoi dong xet xir chap nhan yeu cau cua nguyen don, khong cong nhan ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T la vo chong.

  • [3.2] Ve con chung:

Ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T cung xac nhan Ba N va ong T co vdi nhau 01 ngudi con chung ten Nguyen Minh D (gidi tinh nam), sinh ngay 18/01/2022. Ba N va ong T co tien hanh lam giay khai sinh cho be Nguyen Minh D tai Uy ban nhan dan plurdng A, quan B theo Giay khai sinh so 65/GKS-BS ngay 10/02/2022.

Xet viec nudi dudng con chung, khoan 3 Dieu 51 Luat hon nhan va gia dinh nam 2014 quy dinh: “Con dudi 36 thong tudi dupe giao cho me true tiep nudi, tru trudng hop ngudi me khong du dieu kien de true tiep trong nom, cham soc, nudi dudng, gido due con hoac cho me cd thoa thuan khac phu hop vdi loi ich cua con Do vay, Hoi dong xet xir xet thay can chap nhan yeu cau cua nguyen don, giao tre Nguyen Minh D (gidi tinh nam), sinh ngay 18/01/2022 cho ba Huynh Thi Hong N true tiep nudi dirong. Viec cap dudng nuoi con: Ba N yeu cau ong T cap dudng nudi con chung 4.000.000 dong/thang; ong T cung dong y vdi yeu cau nay nen Hoi dong xet xir chap nhan yeu cau cua ba N ve viec ong T cd trach nhiem cap dudng nudi con chung moi thang 4.000.000 dong (bon trieu dong). Cac ben da tir thoa thuan viec cap dudng se tir ngay 01 den ngay 05 duong lich hang thang, bat \   <9

dau thirc hien tir thang 5 nam 2024 den khi con chung du 18 tudi hoac cd can cir r         r                                             yr

chain dirt viec cap dudng nudi con theo quy dinh phap luat. Viec giao nhan tien cap dudng se do ba N va ong T tir thirc hien hoac tai co quan thi hanh an dan sir cd 9                     \          r

tham quyen. Truong hop han chot thdi han cap dudng roi vao ngay nghi, ngay le 9                                                         r                                              r

ma khong the thirc hien duoc viec cap dudng thi viec cap dudng se duoc thirc hien vao ngay ngay lam viec tiep theo sau do.

Ngubi khong true tiep nuoi con co quyen, nghia vu tham nom con ma khong ai duoc can trb.

Cha, me true tiep nudi con cung cac thanh vien gia dinh khong duoc can tro ngubi khong true tiep nudi con trong viec tham nom, chain soc, nudi duong, giao due con.

Cha, me khong true tiep nuoi con lam dung quyen tham nom de can tro hoac gay anh hubng xau den viec trong nom, chain soc, nuoi duong, giao due con thi • • ' • ' ' ' '

ngubi true tiep nuoi con co quyen yeu cau Toa an han che quyen tham nom con cua ngubi do. Vi loi ich cua con chung theo yeu cau cua mot hoac ca hai ben, Toa 9               r                                         9                                             r                                                                        r

an co the quyet dinh thay doi ngubi true tiep nuoi con hoac muc cap duong nuoi con chung.

• [3.3] Ve tai san chung va no chung: Ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T deu xac dinh khong co, khong yeu cau Toa an giai quyet nen Hoi dong xet xu khong xem xet.

• [3.4] Xet de nghi cua dai dien Vien kiem sat phu hop vbi nhan dinh neu tren nen co co sb chap nhan.

• [4] Ve an phi:

Nguyen don la ba Huynh Thi Hong N chiu an phi hon nhan gia dinh so tham doi vbi tranh chap khong cong nhan quan he vo chong. Ong Nguyen Ngoc T chiu an phi cap duong nuoi con theo quy dinh phap luat.

V't cac le tren,

QUYET DINH:

• - Can cu khoan 1 Dieu 28; diem a khoan 1 Dieu 35; Dieu 36; diem a khoan 1 Dieu 39; Dieu 271; khoan 1 Dieu 273 Bo luat To tung Dan su nam 2015;

• - Can cu Dieu 9, Dieu 14, Dieu 55, Dieu 56, Dieu 57, khoan 3 Dieu 51, Dieu 82, Dieu 83, Dieu 84, Dieu 116, Dieu 117 va Dieu 118 cua Luat Hon nhan va Gia dinh;

• - Can cu khoan 4 Dieu 3 Thong tu lien tich so 01/2016/TTLT-TANDTC- VKSNDTC-BTP ngay 06 thang 01 nam 2016 cua Toa an nhan dan toi cao - Vien

9                                                     r                                    '

kiem sat nhan dan toi cao - Bo Tu phap hubng dan thi hanh mot so quy dinh cua Luat lion nhan va gia dinh;

• - Can cu diem a khoan 5 Dieu 27; diem a khoan 6 Dieu 27 cua Nghi quyet so 326/2016/UBTVQH14 ngay 30 thang 12 nam 2016 cua Uy ban Thubng vu Quoc hoi; Luat Thi hanh an Dan sir.

• - Can cu Luat phi va le phi so 97/2015/QH13 ngay 25/11/2015;

Xu: Chap nhan toan bo yeu cau khbi kien cua nguyen don - ba Huynh Thi Hong N.

• 1. Ve lion nhan: Khong cong nhan quan he vo chong giira ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T.

• 2. Ve con chung: ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T co 01 ngubi con chung ten Nguyen Minh D (gibi tinh nam), sinh ngay 18/01/2022 theo Giay khai sinh so 65/GKS-BS ngay 10/02/2022 do Uy ban nhan dan phirbng A, quan B cap. Giao con chung la tre Nguyen Minh D cho ba Huynh Thi Hong N true tiep

                                            r                                                                                                                   \                    r

nuoi dubng. Ong T co nghia vu cap dubng nuoi con chung 4.000.000 dong (Bon trieu dong) mot thang vao ngay 01 den ngay 05 duong lich hang thang, bat dau r                                                                            *>                                                            r

thuc hien tu thang 5 nam 2024 den khi con chung du 18 tuoi hoac co can cir chain dirt viec cap dubng nudi con theo quy dinh phap luat. Viec giao nhan tien cap dubng se do ba N, ong T tu thuc hien hoac tai co quan thi hanh an dan str co tham ' ___ '

quyen. Truong hop han chot thbi han cap dubng roi vao ngay nghi, ngay le ma 9                                                         r                                              r

khong the thuc hien duoc viec cap dubng thi viec cap dubng se duoc thuc hien vao ngay ngay lam viec tiep theo sau do.

Ngubi khong true tiep nudi con cd quyen, nghia vu tham nom con ma khong ai duoc can trb.

Cha, me true tiep nuoi con cung cac thanh vien gia dinh khong duoc can trb ngubi khong true tiep nuoi con trong viec tham nom, cham soc, nudi dubng, giao due con.

r                                                                           \                                           *>

Cha, me khong true tiep nuoi con lam dung quyen tham nom de can trb hoac gay anh hubng xau den viec trong nom, cham soc, nuoi dubng, giao due con thi • • ^r • ' ' ' '

ngubi true tiep nuoi con co quyen yeu cau Toa an han che quyen tham nom con cua ngubi do. Vi loi ich cua con chung theo yeu cau cua mot hoac ca hai ben, Toa 9               r                                         9                                             r                                                                        r

an co the quyet dinh thay doi ngubi true tiep nuoi con hoac muc cap dubng nuoi con chung.

• 4. Ve tai san chung va no chung: Ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T tu khai khong co, khong yeu cau Toa an giai quyet nen Toa an khong xem xet.

• 5. Ve an phi: Ba Huynh Thi Hong N chiu an phi lion nhan gia dinh so tham 300.000 dong (ba tram nghin dong) duoc tru vao sb tien tarn ung an phi da nop theo bien lai sb BLTU/23P 0036069 ngay 25/3/2024 cua Chi cue Thi hanh an dan sir Quan 5, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh. Ba Huynh Thi Hong N da thuc hien xong. Ong Nguyen Ngoc T phai chiu an phi cap dubng nuoi con 300.000 dong (ba tram

\                                                                                                                                                       9

nghin dong), thuc hien tai co quan thi hanh an dan sir co tham quyen.

• 6. Quyen khang cao: Ba Huynh Thi Hong N va ong Nguyen Ngoc T co

\                                                                                     9

quyen khang cao trong han 15 ngay ke tu ngay duoc tong dat hop le ban an. Vien z                                9                                                      r

kiem sat nhan dan cung cap, Vien kiem sat nhan dan cap tren diroc quyen khang nghi theo quy dinh cua Bo luat to tung Dan sir.

nhan: TM. HOI DONG XET xtr SO THAM

THAM PHAN - TAND Tp. HCM; - VKSND Quan 5; - Chi cue THADS Quan 5; - Cac duong sir: - Luu: VP. ho so.

THAM PHAN - CHU TOA PHIEN TOA • Do Thi Ngoc Bich