TOA AN NHAN DAN     CONG HO A XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM

HUYEN YEN THANH             Doc lap - Tir do - Hanh phuc

TINH NGHE AN               ’ —-^::-

Ban an so:72/2024/HNGD-ST

Ngay 30 thang 5 nam 2024

“V/V Tranh chap ve hdn nhan gia dinh”

NHAN DANH

NLOC CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM

• • •

TOA AN NHAN DAN HUYEN YEN THANH - TiNH NGHE AN • •

Thanh ph an Hoi dong xet xii so" th am gom co.

9                                                                                       /\

Tham phan - Chu too phien toa: Ong Vu Anh Ngoc

Cdc hoi tham nhan dan: Ong Nguyen Van Dung - Ba Nguyen Thi Ha. Thic ky phien toa: Ba Hoang Thi Tinh - Thu ky Toa an nhan dan huyen Yen Thanh - tinh Nghe An.

z/zezt Vien kiem sat nhan dan huyen Yen Thanh - tinh Nghe An tham gia phien toa: Khong tham gia.

Trong ngay 30 thang 5 nam 2024 tai Toa an nhan dan huyen Yen Thanh, tinh Nghe An xet xu so tham cong khai vu an Hdn nhan va gia dinh thu ly so: 89/2024/TLST-HNGD ngay 20 thang 02 nam 2024 ,ve viec Tranh chap Hon nhan va gia dinh theo Quyet dinh dua vu an ra xet xu sd:147/2024/QDXX-ST ngay 24 thang 04 nam 2024 va Quyet dinh hoan phien toa so 46/2024/QD-HPT ngay 10 thang 05 nam 2024, giua cac duong sir:

-Nguyen don: Chi Le Thi V, sinh ngay 06/3/1994.

Noi cu tru: xom P, xa P, huyen Y, tinh Nghe An. ( Vang mat co ly do, co don de nghi xet xu vang mat)

-Bi don: Anh Nguyen Khac S, sinh ngay 20/12/1991.

Noi cu tru: xom P, xa P, huyen Y, tinh Nghe An.(Vang mat lan thu 2 tai phien toa khong co ly do).

NOI DUNG VU AN: • •

Theo noi dung don klidi kien, trinh bay tai ban khai va trinh bay cua nguyen don tai phien toa thi vu an co noi dung.

- Ve quan he hdn nhan: Chi Le Thi V va anh Nguyen Khac S to chuc cudi vao nam 2012.Trude khi cudi anh chi co qua trinh tim hieu, yeu duong, tu nguyen Z                                                  9

tien tdi hdn nhan, da to chuc cudi hoi theo phong tuc tap quan dia phuong duoc str dong y cua hai gia dinh. Luc cudi chua la thu tuc dang ky ket lion.Den thang 5/2015 chi V, anh S moi lam thu tuc dang ky ket lion tai UBND xa P, huyen Y, tinh Nghe An duoc cap giay chung nhan ket lion so: 58/2015 ngay 04/5/2015. Sau khi cudi vo chong khong song hanh phuc dau nam 2023 thi phat sinh mau thuan.Nguyen nhan chu yeu qua trinh song chung vo chong khong hop nhau ve moi

mat, khong tim dirge tieng noi chung trong lion nhan,vg thirdng xuyen va chain vdi nhau qua ldi noi, hanh dong, gay kho chiu cho nhau. Mau thuan xay ra ngay cang sau sac tram trong, nen vg chong da song ly than cat dirt cac moi quan quan he tir thang 2/2023 cho den nay. Mau thuan xay ra da dirge gia dinh hai ben vun ven de vg chong cung nhau xay dung hong nhan ben vung, nhung tinh cam vg chong van khong dugc cai thien, ngirgc lai mau thuan cang tram trong lion.

Chi V xac dinh khong con tinh cam, tinh yeu doi vdi anh S nira, du co hoa giai den dau thi chi V cung khong doan tu, khong duy tri lion nhan doi vdi anh S, do vay chi de nghi Toa giai quyet cho toi ly hon anh Nguyen Khac S.

-Ve quan he con chung: Vg chong cd 02 con chung chau Nguyen Gia B (Gidi tinh: nam), sinh ngay 17/10/2012 va chau Nguyen Thi Thuy T (Gidi tinh: nir), sinh ngay 31/8/2018. Tir ngay vg chong song ly than chi V dang true tiep chain soc nuoi duong chau Nguyen Thi Thuy T (Gidi tinh: nir), sinh ngay 31/8/2018,anh Nguyen Khac S dang true tiep chain soc nuoi dirdng chau Nguyen Gia B (Gidi tinh: nam), sinh ngay 17/10/2012. Neu ly lion chi V de nghi giao chau Nguyen Thi Thuy T (Gidi tinh: nir), sinh ngay 31/8/2018 cho chi V true tiep chain soc nuoi dirdng, giao chau Nguyen Gia B (Gidi tinh: N), sinh ngay 17/10/2012 cho anh Nguyen Khac S true tiep chain soc nuoi dirdng, cac ben khong phai dong gop \           r

tien cap dirdng nuoi con chung cho nhau.

- Ve quan he tai san: Chi Le Thi V khong yeu cau Toa an giai quyet.

Doi vdi bi don anh Nguyen Khac S da dirge Toa an niem yet, tong dat hgp le r                                             x                                                                                              •>                                   r

cac van ban to tung, yeu cau anh co mat tai toa an de giai quyet vu an, nhung anh S r

khong hgp tac, nen Toa an khong thu thap dirge y kien, ldi khai cua bi don. Song qua cac tai lieu,chung cu do nguyen don cung cap thi ve quan he lion nhan, nguyen nhan mau thuan dan den lion nhan giira chi Le Thi V va anh Nguyen Khic S tan ra 9

do vd co ban dung nlnr nguyen don da trinh bay.

NHAN DINH CUA TOA AN:

• •

[l]Ve to tung: Quan he phap luat ma ma nguyen don yeu cau Toa an giai quyet la vu an Tranh chap lion nhan va gia dinh thuoc tham quyen giai quyet cua Toa an nhan dan quy dinh tai klioan 1 Dieu 28 Bd luat to tung dan sir. Nguyen don, bi don deu cu tru tai xdni P, xa P, huyen Y, tinh Nghe An nen vu an thuoc tham quyen giai quyet cua Toa an nhan dan huyen Yen Thanh, tinh Nghe An qui dinh tai Dieu 35 va Dieu 39 cua Bo luat to tung dan sir.

Toa an da niem yet tong dat hgp le cac van ban to tung, yeu cau nguyen don, bi don co mat tai toa an de giai quyet, nhung bi don khong chap hanh, khong hgp tac. Do do Toa an da lap bien ban theo trinh tir quy dinh cua Bo luat to tung dan sir •>        ,     ,                  r

lam co so de giai quyet vu an.

Quyet dinh dira vu an ra xet xir, giay bao tham gia phien toa lan thu nhat da dugc niem yet, tong dat le cho cac duong sir.Tai phien toa lan thu nhat nguyen don r                                                         \                                            r                                                    r

vang mat cd ly do, de nghi xet xu vang mat, bi don vang mat khong cd ly do, Hoi dong xet xu da Quyet dinh hoan phien toa, an dinh ve thdi gian tiep tuc xet xu vu

an.Toa an tiep tuc niem yet, tong dat, hop le Quyet dinh hoan phien toa va Giay bao tham gia phien toa lan thu hai cho cac duong su. Tai phien toa lan thu hai r                                            \                                      r                                             r                   r

nguyen don vang mat co don de nghi xet xu vang mat, bi don tiep tuc vang mat khong co ly do. Can cu diem b, khoan 2 Dieu 227 va Dieu 228 cua Bo luat to tung \                                       z                                                                    r                             r

dan su, Hoi dong xet xu, tien hanh xet xu vu an vang mat doi vdi nguyen don chi Le Thi VI va bi don anh Nguyen Khac S.

[2]Ve noi dung:

- Ve quan he lion nhan: Dieu kien ket hon, trinh tu thu tuc tien tdi hon nhan giua chi Le Thi V, anh Nguyen Khac S duoc cac ben thuc hien dung quy dinh cua phap luat. Chi V, anh S tu nguyen tien tdi hon nhan, da lam thu tuc dang ky ket hon tai UBND xa P, huyen Y, tinh Nghe An, duoc cap giay chung nhan ket hon so:58, ngay 04/5/2015 nenxac dinh hon nhan giua chi Le Thi V va anh Nguyen Khac S la hon nhan hop phap.

Mau thuan co ban dan den hon nhan giua chi V, anh S tan ra, do vd la sau mot qua trinh song chung thi chi V thay vo chong khong hop nhau ve moi mat, khong tim r                           r                                                                                                                                                                                          r

duoc tieng noi, loi di chung trong hon nhan, nen xung dot cu cai trong cube song chung thudng xuyen xay ra, vo chong da co nhung ldi noi, xu su khong dung muc doi vdi nhau. Hon nhan giua chi V, anh S tan ra do vo ke tu thang 02/2023.Tu ngay vo chong song ly than den ngay xet xu cac ben khong co dong thai gi ve viec mu keo hon nhan. Tu do cho thay hon nhan giua chi V, anh S da thuc su tan ra, do r           r

vd, soi day gan ket tinh cam giua hai ngudi khong con, muc dich hon nhan khong dat duoc nhu mong muon cua cac ben. Nay chi V yeu cau Toa an giai quyet cho anh duoc ly hon anh S la co can cu, can ap dung Dieu 56 cua Luat hon nhan va gia dinh xu cho chi Le Thi V duoc ly hon anh Nguyen Khac S.

\                                                                                 r                                                                        r

- Ve quan he con chung: Qua trinh song ly than chi V dang true tiep chain soc nuoi duong chau thu hai, anh S dang nuoi duong chau dau.Viec de nghi giao con theo hien trang cua chi V la phu hop vdi phap luat, phu hop vdi nguyen vong cua con chung. Do do chi V de nghi giao chau Nguyen Thi Thuy T (Gidi tinh: nu), sinh ngay 31/8/2018 cho chi V nuoi true tiep chain soc nuoi dudng va giao chau Nguyen Gia B (Gidi tinh: nam), sinh ngay 17/10/2012 cho anh S true tiep chain soc nuoi dudng la hoan toan cd co so can nhan, viec de nghi giao nuoi con cua chi Le Thi V la phu hop vdi phap luat, dao due xa hoi, phu hop vdi nguyen vong con chung. Do do chap nhan de nghi giao nuoi con chung cua chi V. Do moi ben nuoi moi chau nen cac ben khong phai cap dudng nuoi con chung cho nhau.

• - Ve quan he tai san: Chi Le Thi V khong yeu cau toa giai quyet, nen khong xem

,     ,                  r

xet giai quyet.

• - Ve an phi: Buoc chi Le Thi V phai nop an phi ly hon so tham.

Vi cac le treri.

QUYET DINH:

Can cu vao Dieu 56; Dieu 81; Dieu 82; Dieu 83; Dieu 84 cua Luat hon nhan va gia dinh.

Xu*:

• 1. Ve quan he tinh cam: Chi Le Thi V dugc ly lion anh Nguyen Khac S.

• 2. Ve quan he con chung: Giao con chung chau Nguyen Thi Thuy T (Gidi tinh: nir), sinh ngay 31/8/2018 cho chi Le Thi V true tiep chain soc nuoi dudng cho den luc

9                                                       9

con chung du tudi tnrdng thanh ( 18 tudi).

Giao con chung chau Nguyen Gia B (Gidi tinh:N),sinh ngay 17/10/2012 cho anh Tran Trong Trung true t chain soc nuoi dudng cho den luc con chung du tudi tnrdng thanh (18 tudi).

Chi Le Thi V, anh Nguyen Khac S khong phai thirc hien nghia vu cap dudng nuoi con chung cho nhau. Cac ben cd quyen va nghia vu di lai tham nom chain soc con chung khong ai duac can trd, ngan cam.

y                    \                      9                                     r

Vi lai ich cua con cac ben cd quyen yeu cau thay doi ngudi true tiep nuoi con va '           r                                       ₉

yeu cau cap dudng nuoi con.

• 3. Ve an phi: Ap dung dieu 147 Bo luat to tung dan sir: Dieu 26: Dieu 27 cua nghi quyet so: 326/2016/UBTVQH14, ngay 30/12/2016 cua Uy ban thirdng vu Quoc Hoi qui dinh ve mire thu, mien giam, thu nop quan ly va sir dung an phi le phi Toa an.

- Buoc: Chi Le Thi V phai nop 300.000d (Ba tram nghin dong) an phi ly lion sa 9             r                            *                      *                                                               r . y

tham. An phi chi V phai nop duac trir vao so tien tarn irng an phi 300.000d (Ba tram nghin dong) chi da nop tai Chi cue thi hanh an dan sir huyen Yen Thanh, tinh Nghe An theo bien lai nop tien so: 0002574 ngay 20/02/2024, chi Le Thi V da nop du an phi ly lion so tham.

y                                                                                            r                                            \

3.Quyen khang cao: Nguyen dan, bi dan vang mat duac quyen khang cao len toa r                          9                                                           9                                                                             r

an cap phuc tham trong han 15 ngay ke tir ngay ban an duac niem yet tai tru sd r

UBND xa P, huyen Y, Nghe An va noi cu tru cuoi cung cua nguyen dan, bi dan.

Noi nhan:

-Cac duong su,

• - VKSND H. Yen Thanh.

• - Chi cue THA DS H. Yen Thanh.

• - TAND tinh Nghe An

• - VKSND tinh Nghe An

• - UBND xa Phuc Thanh

• - LuuHSVA

• - UBND xa Phuc Thanh (Noi DKKH)