TOA AN NHAN DAN HUYEN TAN KY TtNH NGHE AN _•

Ban an so: 38 /2024/HS-ST

Ngay: 08 / 5 /2024.

NHAN DANH

NIOC CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM • • •

TOA AN NHAN DAN HUYEN TAN KY - TtNH NGHE AN • •

Thanh phan Hoi dong xet xu gom cd:

9

Tham phan - Chit toq phien toa: Ong Dang Xuan Hoan

Cdc Hoi tham nhan clan:

• 1. Ba: Nguyen Thi Van Anh.

2. Ba: Vu Thi Thanh Huang.

Thu ky phien toa: Ba: Le Thi Quyen - Thu ky Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky , tinh Nghe An.

Dai dien vien kiem sat nhan dan huyen Tan Ky tham gia phien toa: —                           9

Ong: Nguyen Van Dan - Kiem sat vien.

Trong ngay 08 thang 5 nam 2024, tai: Tru so Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky, tinh Nghe An, xet xu so tham cong khai vu an hinh su thu ly so: 26/2024/HSST, ngay 09/4/2024, theo Quyet dinh dua vu an ra xet xu so: 41/2024/QDXXST-HS ngay 24 thang 4 nam 2024 cua Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky, tinh Nghe An, doi vdi bi cao:

Ho va ten: Le Van H- Gidi tinh: Nam; Ten goi khac: Khong; Sinh ngay: 10/9/1976 tai huyen T, tinh Nghe An; Noi cu tru: Xom T, xa H, huyen T, Nghe An, Quoc tich: Viet Nam;Dan toe: Kinh; Ton giao: Khong; Nghe nghiep: Lai xe; Chuc vu (Dang, chinh quyen, doan the): Khong; Trinh do van hoa: 03/12; Con ong: Le Van CSinh nam: 1950 va ba: Nguyen Thi LSinh nam: 1950; Vo: Tran Thi TSinh nam: 1978; Con: Co 03 con, con Ion nhat 26 tuoi, con nho nhat 22 tuoi; Tien an, tien su: Khong; Bi cao bi ap dung bien phap “Cam di khoi noi cu tru” tir ngay 28/01/2024 den nay tai dia phuong.. Co mat.

Bi hai:

• 1- Chi Dao Thi Hl-Sinh nam: 1975 ( Da chet)

Tru tai: Xom 6, xa Nghia Binh, huyen Tan Ky, tinh Nghe An

• 2- Tran Van H2sinh nam: 1975. Vang mat.( Da uy quyen cho anh Tran Van M con de

Tru tai: Xom F, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe An

Ngu’d’i dai dien hop phap cho bi hai chi Dao Thi Hl va diro’c bi hai anh Tran Van H2 quyen: ( Con de)

Anh: Tran Van Ml nam: 2000. Co mat.

Tru tai: Xom F, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe An

NOI DUNG VU AN • •

Theo cac tai lieu co trong ho so vu an va dien bien tai phien toa, noi dung z

vu an diroc tom tat nhir sau:

Vao khoang 11 gib 00 phut ngay 15/12/2022, do tai xe lai xe bi om nen Le Van H3 chu phuong tien nhung khong co giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh (Loai FC) da dieu khien xe 6 to dau keo, kiem kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc, bien kiem soat: 37R- 031.72 cho keo go tu xa H, huyen T den huyen N, tinh Nghe Ande nhap ban go keo. Khi Le Van H4 khien xe 6 to den each Nga tu giao nhau vdi dubng khong iru tien tai Km 672 + 500 dubng H thuoc xom F, xa N, huyen T khoang 50 den 60 met thi phat hien anh Tran Van H5 nam: 1975, tru tai: Xom F, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe Andang dieu khien xe mb to, bien kiem soat: 37X4 - 1867 cho sau chi Dao Thi H6 nam: 1975 (La vo cua anh H7 di chuyen tu dubng khong iru tien chay cat qua dubng H hirdng tu phai qua trai theo chieu di chuyen cua xe 6 to do Le Van H4 khien. Thay vay, Le Van H8 giam toe do ma ra phanh, dong thbi danh lai sang ben trai de tranh xe mo to do anh Tran Van H9 khien, khi khoang each giira 02 (hai) xe con khoang r          r                                                                                                                                        r                    *>

15 met, thay sap xay ra tai nan nen Le Van H10 keo phanh lop ke de xe dung lai, dong thbi danh lai sang phan dubng cua xe di nguoc chieu de tranh xay ra vu tai 9 nan nhung do xe 6 to do Le Van H4 khien cho nang co quan tinh lbn nen xe khong dung lai ma tiep tuc tinh tien sang toan bo phan dubng cua xe di nguoc chieu nen da dam true dien vao phia ben trai xe mo to do anh Tran Van H9 khien gay ra vu tai nan giao thong. Hau qua: Chi Dao Thi Hltu vong tren dubng di cap cuu; anh Tran Van Hl 1 thuong nang phai di cap cuu; xe mb to va o to bi hu hong.

Sau khi sir viec xay ra Co quan canh sat dieu tra Cong an huyen T tien hanh tiirng cau giam dinh nguyen nhan chet, giam dinh dau vet co hoc vu tai nan giao thong, dong thbi thu giu doan video chira dir lieu ghi lai vu tai nan giao thong..

* Ket qua kham nghiem hien trubng: (But luc so: 49- 50 HSVA).

• 1. Mb ta hien trubng:

Hien trubng noi xay tai nan duoc xac dinh tai doan km 672+500 dubng H thuoc xom F, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe AnDubng doan dubng nay la dubng

thang, dudng H tir mep phia dong den mep phia tay rong 9,8m, phia bac di huyen N di thi tran T, huyen T, tinh Nghe AnGiua dudng co vach ke son dirt quang man vang chia lam hai lan chieu xe chay, doan nay co giao vdi dudng lien xom hudng Tay di xom F xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe Anhudng Ddi vao xom N, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe AnTam nhin doan giao nhau bi che khuat d goc phia dong nam co ruong mia. Duong hudng di xom N, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe '                                                                        r          x                                                                     r

Anco do doc khoang 10 do, chan ddc nam d hudng tay, dinh doc d hudng dong, mat dudng H rai nhua bang phang.

• 2. Chon chieu, hudng, xac dinh moc cd dinh:

• - Lay bien bao H5/672 d mep dudng P dudng Hlam moc.

• - Lay vach ke tim dudng Hlam mep chuan.

• - Tien hanh kham nghiem theo chieu tir thi tran T di huyen N, tinh Nghe Anthay:

r                                                                                  r                                                                                                  x

+ Vet phanh dang phanh banh lop keo dai 44,5m, rong 60cm chieu hudng tir thi tran T di huyen N dau tien each mep chuan 0,8m, each diem moc ve phia Nghia Dan la 56m thuoc phan dudng phia Dong, vet lien tuc, diem cuoi ket thuc tai day banh lop sau ciing ben trai ro mooc bien kiem soat: 37R-031.72 (Ky hieu so 01 tren so do hien trudng).

r                                                                                                                                9             \            \                                                   9

+ Vet phanh kep tren mat dudng Hdai 7m, diem dau nam tren mep chuan va nam ngang so vdi mep dudng phia Nam dudng lien xom di vao xom N rong 60cm, chieu hudng tir thi tran T di huyen N dudng phia T dudng Hdiem cuoi each mep chuan 0,8. (Ky hieu so 02 tren so do).

+ Tren mat dudng cd vet cay truot xirdc mat dudng nhua khong lien tuc dai 31m, rong nhat 1,2m, chieu hudng tir thi tran T di huyen N dau vet vi tri gan nhat each mep chuan 0,6m, diem cuoi ket thiic tai cac bo phan phia ben phai xe mo to, bien kiem soat: 37X4-1867, dau vet nam ngang so vdi dau vet so 02. (Ky hieu so 03 tren so do).

+ Tren mat dudng va muong thoat nude phia tay co viing manh vd nhua, kinh, kim loai cac bo phan xe mo to nam rai rac keo dai tir dau dau vet d vi tri so 2 va 3 den vi tri xe 6 to so 5, tir phan dudng phia tay den muong nude phia tay va le dudng. (Ky hieu so 04 tren hien trudng).

+ Xe 6 to dau keo bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 keo ro mooc bien kiem soat: 37R - 031.72 sau tai nan dirng do tren phan dudng phia tay, dau xe hudng huyen Nduoi xe hudng huyen T banh trade va banh sau ciing ciia xe each mep chuan lan luot la lm va 1,05m. (Ky hieu so 05 tren hien trudng).

+ Tren muong thoat nirdc va phan dudng phia tay nam ngang vdi banh lop phia sau ben trai (Day banh lop thir ba tir sau ra trade ciia ro mooc) co viing dau vet mau chay dong khong lien tuc, 01 (mot) chiec ung mau cam, 01 (mot) chiec mu tren dien tich (l,7xl,4)m. (Ky hieu so 6 tren so do).

+ Xe mo to, bien kiem soat: 37X4 - 1867, sau tai nan nam nga nghieng ben phai dau xe hudng Tay, duoi xe hudng Dong tren phan dudng phia Tl(Nam dudi a           a                            a                                  z                                                                                                                 r

gam dau xe o to dau keo vi tri so 5), do tir tarn true banh trade va banh sau den mep chuan lan luot la 3,15m va 1,9m. (Ky hieu so 07 tren so do).

* Ket qua kham nghiem cac plnrong tien:

• 1. Kham nghiem xe mo to, bien kiem soat: 37X4-1867 the hien:

• - Cac bo phan bang kinh, nhira tren xe mo to da bi gay vo, rdi khoi xe.

r           r                       x                                                                                                 '

• - Banh trade bi cong gap vanh, lop het hoi, be mat bi traot xudc bam dinh chat

z

mau trang, mau den, cum tay lai bi traot xirdc cong gap kim loai khong lien tuc.

• - Cum tay lai bi traot xirdc cong gap kim loai khong lien tuc.

• - Dau ngoai num cao su ben trai tay lai cd dau vet traot xudc tren dien (03x02)cm, be mat bam dinh chat mau den, mau trang.

A                                                                                             Z                                      9

• - Cac bo phan bang kim loai phia ben trai xe: Nap may, gia de chan trade, gia de

Z                                  A         Z

chan sau, dp hop xich, can so, ong giam xoc, gia nang xe bi traot xudc gay vo, cong venh khong lien tuc be mat bam dinh chat mau den. Canh yem hai ben vo Z                                            Z

rdi khoi xe, dp nhira than xe, dp nhira sirdn xe bi gay vo rdi khoi xe kiem tra Z

thay be mat bi traot vo traot xudc khong lien tuc, yen xe bat bung khoi xe.

• - Cac bo phan phia ben phai xe: Tay lai, dau ngoai ban dap chan phanh gia de

9                                                                  Z                                                                                     Z

chan trade, gia de chan sau, mat ngoai ong xa, gia nang xe cd cac dau vet traot xudc cong venh khong lien tuc be mat bam dinh chat mau trang.

9                                                                                                             Z           A

• - Kiem tra cac bo phan kinh, vo nhira thay be mat bi traot xudc, nut vo be mat bam dinh chat ban.

• 2. Kham nghiem plnrong tien xe o to dau keo bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien kiem soat: 37R - 031.72 the hien:

• - Tren thung ro mooc chd nhieu cay go tram diroc phu bat nilon.

9        Z

• - Bien so xe bi cong venh, mop lorn traot xudc son, kim loai khong lien tuc tren dien (23x16)cm chieu hirdng dau vet traot xudc tir trade ra sau, vi tri cao nhat each dat 95cm.

• - Op kim loai phia trade dau xe (ba do soc trade) cd viing dau vet mop lorn kich tlnrdc (4x2,5)cm, chieu hirdng dau vet tir trade ra sau, cao each dat 105cm, each thanh xe ben trai 105cm.

• - Mat trade ba do soc trade, dp kim loai phia dirdi ba do soc nay cd viing dau vet traot xudc nut vo, mop lorn kim loai, nhira khong lien tuc, be mat sach bui dat, bam dinh chat mau do trang, tren dien (130x42)cm, chieu hudng tir trade ra sau.

• - Mat dudi cac bo phan phia trade dau xe (Gam dau xe) true banh trade, binh dau, thanh so ngang bi truot xudc, cong mop kim loai sach bui dat khong lien tuc chieu hudng tu* trade ve sau.

• - Ma trong lop trade ben trai co cac vet truot xudc sang cao su khong lien tuc, chieu hudng nguoc chieu quay tien banh xe.

• * Tai ket luan so 49/KL-KTHS (DVCH) ngay 28/02/2023 cua Phong KCong an tinh Nket luan:

• 1. Tai thdi diem xay ra tai nan:

• - Xe o to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R-031.72 di chuyen tren dudng H hudng tu thi tran T, huyen T di huyen N mo to bien so

9                                                                                                                                      9

37X4-1867 di chuyen theo hudng tu phai sang trai so vdi hudng di chuyen cua xe d to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R-031.72.

• - Xe mo to bien so 37X4-1867 dang d phan phia T dudng Hxe 6 to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R-031.72 dang d ca hai phan phia Tay va phia Dong dudng H

• 2. Xe o to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R- 031.72 va xe mo to bien so 37X4-1867 cd va chain vdi nhau:

• - Vi tri va chain dau tien:

+ Tren hien trudng: d phan phia T dudng H

+ Tren xe o to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R-031.72: 0 mat trade dau xe o to bien so 37H-014.19.

+ Tren xe mo to bien so 37X4-1867: 6 phia ben trai xe.

r                                                                      *>             r

• 3. Khong xac dinh duoc toe do cua xe 6 to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R-031.72 va xe mo to bien so 37X4-1867 tai thdi diem xay ra tai nan.

• 4. Xe 6 to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R-031.72 cd va chain vdi tu thi Dao Thi Hl

• - Vi tri va chain dau tien:

+ Tren hien trudng: O phia Tay dudng H

+ Tren xe o to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R-031.72: 0 mat trade dau xe o to bien so 37H-014.19.

+ Tren tu thi: 0 phia ben trai co the.

• - Tu the va chain dau tien: Khi mat lan cac banh lop xe o to bien so 37H-014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc bien so 37R-031.72 dang tiep xue vdi mat dudng, mat trade co the tu thi Dao Thi Hl hudng di xom F, xa N sau co the hudng ve xom N, xaN

• * Tai ban ket luan giam dinh so 2391/KL-KTHS ngay 08 thang 9 nam 2023 cua VBoClket luan:

• - Khong tim thay dau vet cat ghep, chinh sua noi dung hinh anh trong tep video mau giam dinh.

r

• - Khong du co so xac dinh toe do cua xe d to va xe mo to ngay trudc va tai thoi diem xay ra tai nan xuat hien trong tep video.

• * Ket qua kham nghiem tu thi chi Dao Thi Hl

• - Trang phuc va cac vat mang theo: Tu thi phia tren ben ngoai mac ao so mi dai tay mau xanh, phia dudi ben ngoai mac quan dai mau den.

• - Nhan dang tu thi: Tu thi da duoc nhan dang.

• - Chieu dai tu thi 143cm, the trang: Khd, lanh.

Z         Z       9                                                 9

• - Cac dau vet, ton thuong tren co the:

+ Ngay tai vung that lung phia sau cd mot vung xay xat, mai miet mat lop thuong bi da, bam tu mau khong lien tuc kich thuoc (25,5xl4)cm. \                                                         9

+ Vung dau phia sau each thang tren giua dudng chan got toe gay sau cd mot vung sung phu ne bam tu mau khong lien tuc, kich thuoc (20x28)cm, tren vung nay each thang tren dudng chan toe tran 14cm cd mot vet thuong kich thuoc (l,5x0,3)cm.

+ Ngay mom khuy tay phai cd mot vet xay xat, mat ldp thuong bi da, bam tu mau khong lien tuc kich thuoc (5,5x4,5)cm.

+ Mu ban tay, ngon tay phai bi xay xat, mai miet, mat ldp thuong bi da, bam tu mau khong lien tuc, kich thuoc (8,5x7)cm.

+ Mu ban tay, ngon tay trai bi xay xat da, bam tu mau khong lien tuc kich thuoc (3x7,5)cm.

+ Tu 1/3 dudi dui trai den 1/3 tren cang chan trai bi xay xat, rach da, sung phu ne, bam tu mau khong lien tuc, kich thuoc (16x23)cm. Tren vung nay ngay sat dau goi trai cd mot vet thuong kich thuoc (6,5x0 l)cm tuong ung vdi vung nay 02 xuong cang chan trai bi gay.

Tat ca cac dau vet da mo ta tren cd hinh dang khong xac dinh, ria va thanh vet thuong dut khong gon, bam tu mau.

9                                                                 y                                                      \                                                        9

• - Mo tu thi (Hoac mot phan tu thi): Vung dau tuong ung vdi ton thuong kham ngoai to chuc dudi da bi bam tu mau nang, xuong hop so bi vd, kich thuoc doan do duoc (10x0,3)cm, mau trong hop so chay ra ngoai qua dudng vd xuong.

Tien hanh giai phau vung dau xong gia dinh nan nhan khong thac mac r                  X 9                                                  9

khieu nai ve ton thuong va giai phau cac vung khac.

• * Tai ban ket luan giam dinh so 293/KL-KTHS(GD-PY) ngay 20 thang 12 nam 2022 cua Phong KCong an tinh Nket luan:

• 1. Dau vet chinh qua giam dinh:

• - Ben ngoai nan nhan bi nhieu vet thuong, xay xat, mai miet, mat lop thuong bi da, rach da, sung phu ne, bam tu mau.

• - Xuong hop so bi vo, mau trong hop so chay ra ngoai qua dudng vo xuong va vet thuong.

• - 02 xuong cang chan trai bi gay.

• 2. Nguyen nhan chet: Vo xuong hop so, xuat huyet nao va gay hai xuong cang chan trai do chan thuong.

Qua trinh dieu tra Le Van H10 khai nhan toan bo hanh vi pham toi cua minh, lbi khai bi cao phu hop vdi ldi khai cua bi hai va phu hop vdi cac tai lieu, chung cir khac da thu thap duoc co tai ho so vu an.

Tai ban Cao trang so: 34/ CT- VKS- TK ngay 14 thang 4 nam 2024 cua Vien kiem sat nhan dan huyen Tan Ky da truy to bi cao: Le Van H ra tnrdc Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky, tinh Nghe An de xet xu ve toi “Vi pham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dudng bo” theo quy dinh tai diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260 Bo luat Hinh sir.

Tai phien toa, Dai dien Vien kiem sat nhan dan huyen Tan Ky giu nguyen quan diem truy to bi cao ve toi danh, dieu luat ap dung nhu noi dung ban Cao trang va de nghi Hoi dong xet xu:

Ve trach nhiem hinh sir: Tuyen bo Le Van H12 toi “Vipham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dieting bo

* Hinh phat chinli: Ap dung diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260, diem b, s khoan 1, khoan 2 Dieu 51, Dieu 65 BLHS xu phat Le Van H13 an 36 thang tu, cho hudng 9 an treo, thdi gian thu thach 60 thang, ke tir ngay tuyen an so tham.

- Hinh phat bd sung:

• b, Trach nhiem dan sir: Khong.

• c, Xu ly vat chung: Khong.

• d, Ve an phi: Ap dung khoan 2 Dieu 136 BLTTHS; diem a khoan 1 Dieu 23 Nghi quyet 326/2016/UBTVQH14 ngay 30/12/2016 ve an phi, le phi Toa an, buoc bi cao Le Van H14 chili 200.000 dong tien an phi HSST

Tai phien toa horn nay bi cao da thanh khan khai bao toan bo hanh vi pham toi cua bi cao, khong co khai nai gi ve noi dung ban cao trang, mong Hoi dong xet xu xem xet giam nhe mire hinh phat cho bi cao..

Ngudi dai dien hap phap cho bi hai chi Dao Thi Hl va duoc bi hai anh Tran Van H2 quyen khong co y gi.

NHAN DINH CUA TOA AN • •

Tren ccr sa noi dung vu an, can cu vao cac tai lieu co trong ho so" vu an da dircrc tham tra, xet hoi, tranh tung tai phien toa, Hoi dong xet xir nhan thay nhir sau:

• [1] Ve to tung: Trong qua trinh dieu tra, tiny to, Co quan dieu tra Cong an huyen T, Vien kiem sat nhan dan huyen Tan Ky, Kiem sat vien da thuc hien dung ve tham quyen, trinh tu, thu tuc theo quy dinh cua Bo luat To tung hinh str (BLTTHS). Tai phien toa, bi cao, Ngubi dai dien hop phap cho bi hai chi Dao Thi Hl va duoc bi hai anh Tran Van H2 quyen khong co y kien, khieu nai gi ve hanh vi, quyet dinh to tung cua co quan tien hanh to tung, ngubi tien hanh to \                                                  r                                                         r                       r                                                              r

tung. Hoi dong xet xu xet thay cac hanh vi, quyet dinh td tung cua co quan tien hanh to tung, ngubi tien hanh to tung da thuc hien dung theo quy dinh cua phap luat.

• [2] Ve noi dung: Trong qua trinh dieu tra cung nhu tai phien toa, bi cao Le Van H da khai nhan hanh vi pham toi ma bi cao da thuc hien, dung nhu noi dung cua ban cao trang da neu va quy ket, khong co khai nai gi khac.

Lbi khai nhan toi cua bi cao tai phien toa phu hop vbi lbi khai tai co quan dieu tra; phu hop vbi ket qua kham nghiem hien trubng, ket qua kham nghiem phuong tien, ket qua kham nghiem tu thi va ket luan giam dinh so 293/KL- KTHS(GD-PY) ngay 20 thang 12 nam 2022 cua Phong KCong an tinh Nket luan:

• 1. Dau vet chinh qua giam dinh:

• - Ben ngoai nan nhan bi nhieu vet thuong, xay xat, mai miet, mat lop thuong bi da, rach da, sung phu ne, bam tu mau.

• - Xuong hop so bi vb, mau trong hop so chay ra ngoai qua dubng vb xuong va vet thuong.

• - 02 xuong cang chan trai bi gay.

• 2. Nguyen nhan chet: Vb xuong hop so, xuat huyet nao va gay hai xuong cang

r                                                                                   y                                       •>       r

chan trai do chan thuong. Nhu vay, da co day du co sb de ket luan: Vao khoang 12 gib 52 phut ngay 15/12/2022, Le Van H8 co giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh dieu khien xe b to, bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 keo theo so mi ro mode, bien 9        '**'9

kiem soat: 37R - 031.72 cho go cay keo di chuyen tren dubng H hubng tu thi tran T hubng di huyen N, tinh Nghe An. Khi den Km 672 + 500 dubng H thuoc xbm F, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe An do khong lam chu toe do, dieu khien xe X                                                                                       '                                                                                                                         9

sang phan dubng cua xe di nguoc chieu nen da dam true dien vao xe mo to, bien kiem soat: 37X4 - 1867 do anh Tran Van H9 khien cho theo chi Dao Thi Hl(La 9

vo cua anh H2dang di chuyen tu ben phai qua ben trai dubng HHau qua: Chi

Dao Thi Hltu vong tren duong di cap cuu; anh Tran Van Hl 1 thuong nang phai dua di cap cuu; Xe o to va xe mo to bi hu hong.

Hanh vi cua Le Van H10 vi pham khoan 9, khoan 23 Dieu 8; khoan 1 Dieu 9 Luat giao thdng duong bo nam 2008, sua doi nam 2019 nen da pham toi “Vipham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thdng ducmg bo ” quy dinh tai diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260 Bo luat Hinh su.

Dieu 8 Luat giao thdng duong bo quy dinh:

“Cac hanh vi bi cam:

\                 9                                                                         <

9. Dieu khien xe ccr gicri khong cd giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh;

23. Hanh vi vi pham quy tac giao thong ducmg bo, hanh vi khac gay nguy hiem cho ngucri vaphucmg tien tham gia giao thong”.

Dieu 9 Luat giao thong duong bo quy dinh: “ Quy tac chung:

1. Nguo’i tham gia giao thdng phdi di ben phdi theo chieu di cua minh, di dung Jan ducmg, phan ducmg quy dinh va phdi chap hanh he thdng bdo hieu ducmg bo

Khi dieu khien xe o to, bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 keo theo so mi ro 9           9

mode, bien kiem soat: 37R - 031.72 cho go cay keo tham gia giao thdng duong bo Le Van H khong cd giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh. Nhu vay, hanh vi pham toi cua bi cao Le Van H da pham vao toi “Vi pham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thdng duong bo”. Toi pham va hinh phat quy dinh tai diem a, khoan 2 Dieu 260 9

Bo luat hinh su, nhu noi dung ban Cao trang Vien kiem sat nhan dan huyen Tan Ky, tinh Nghe An truy to la dung nguoi dung toi, dung phap luat.

• [3] Vu an mang tinh chat rat nghiem trong. Hanh vi pham toi cua bi cao Le Van H da true tiep xam pham den tinh mang va sue khoe cua nguoi khac, gay anh huong xau den trat tu tri an tren dia ban, gay tarn ly hoang mang lo lang trong mot bo phan quan chung nhan dan tai dia ban khi tham gia giao thdng.

Khi dieu khien o to bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 keo theo so mi ro 9             9

mode, bien kiem soat: 37R - 031.72 tham gia giao thdng, bi cao nhan thuc duoc \                          9                                               9                                        \

do la nguon nguy hiem cao do, nguy hiem cho xa hoi, can phai chu y quan sat, lam chu toe do, nhung do chu quan chay qua toe do quy dinh, tranh vuot sai quy dinh, khong di dung phan duong, lan duong, nen khi den Km 672 + 500 duong H thuoc xom F, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe An da dam true dien vao xe mo to, bien kiem soat: 37X4 - 1867 do anh Tran Van H9 khien cho theo chi Dao Thi Hl (La vo cua anh H2dang di chuyen tu ben phai qua ben trai duong HHau qua:

Chi Dao Thi Hltu vong tren dubng di cap cuu; anh Tran Van Hl 1 thirong nang phai dua di cap cuu. Hon nua, hanh vi bi cao khong co giay phep lai xe theo quy 5              9                                                                                                                                   r

dinh ma dieu khien phuong tien tham gia giao thong gay tai nan dan den hau qua chet ngubi. Vi vay can co dudng loi xu phat nghiem minh, tuong xung vbi tinh r                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  *>                *>

chat, mire do hanh vi pham toi ma bi cao da thirc hien de the hien tinh nghiem minh cua phap luat.

• [4] Ve tinh tiet tang nang, giam nhe:

Ve tinh tiet tang nang: Bi cao khong co tinh tiet tang nang.

Ve tinh tiet giam nhe: Qua trinh dieu tra, bi cao da thanh khan khai bao; sau khi xay ra tai nan dan den chi Dao Thi Hl5 vong bi cao da kip thbi tham hoi, dong vien, boi thubng cho gia dinh bi hai nen duoc dai dien gia dinh bi hai viet don xin giam nhe hinh phat. Vi vay, bi cao duoc huong cac tinh tiet giam nhe trach nhiem hinh sir quy dinh tai diem b, s khoan 1, khoan 2 Dieu 51 BTHS. Xet thay, bi cao Le Van H12 toi rat nghiem trong vbi loi vb y nhung ban r                                                                            r

than bi cao co nhan than tot, bi cao khong co tinh tiet tang nang va duoc huong nhieu tinh tiet giam nhe duoc quy dinh tai Dieu 51 Bo luat hinh sir, nen chua can thiet each ly bi cao ra ngoai xa hoi, ma ap dung Dieu 65 Bo luat hinh su, xu bi cao hinh phat tu nhung cho huong an treo, giao bi cao cho chinh quyen dia 9

phuong noi bi cao cu tru giao due cung du nghiem, nhu dai dien Vien kiem sat nhan dan huyen Tan Ky da de nghi la co can cu, de bi cao co co hoi cai tao, tu '                                                                                      5                9

duong trb thanh ngubi cong dan tot cho gia dinh va xa hoi, nham the hien tinh khoan hong cua phap luat xa hoi chu nghia.

Ve hinh phat bo sung: Tai khoan 5 Dieu 260 Bo luat hinh sir quy dinh: “Ngucri pham toi con cd the bi cam dam nhiem chuc vu, cam hanh nghe hoac lam cong viec nhat dinh tir 01 ndm den 05 ndm Qua xac minh, bi cao khong dam nhiem chuc vu hay hanh nghe trong mot linh virc nhat dinh nao nen mien hinh phat bo sung cho bi cao.

• [5] Ve trach nhiem dan sir: Bi cao da tu nguyen boi thubng thiet hai cho bi hai va gia dinh bi hai, vbi so tien: 250.000.000 dong (Hai tram ndm muo'i trieu dong) nay bi hai va dai dien hop phap cho bi hai khong co yeu cau gi them, dong thbi co don xin giam nhe hinh phat cho Le Van H, nen Hoi dong xet xu mien xet.

[6] Ve vat chung vu an: Trong qua trinh dieu tra co thu gin:

• (1) 01 (Mot) phong bi niem phong cua VBo Cl ben trong chua dia DVD chua dir lieu vu tai nan giao thong. Xet day la tai lieu chirng minh hanh vi pham toi cua bi cao nen Co quan dieu tra da dira vao liru trir tai ho so vu an.

• (2) 01 (Mot) xe mo to bien so 37X4 - 1867 mau den, do co so may VMVA2EH - 508086, so khung GSC10BH7H - 508086 xe da qua su dung va bi lnr hong do tai nan giao thong.

• (3) 01 (Mot) xe 6 to nhan hieu CNHTC, so loai ZZ4257 co so may: WD61596E150317014237, so khung: LZZ5CLSB1FN076996 mau do, mang

9           9

bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 xe da qua su dung keo theo so mi ro mooc nhan hieu CIMIC co so khung LJRH13381FN032253 mang bien so 37R - 031.72 xe 6 to va so mi ro mooc deu da qua su dung.

Doi vdi: 01 (Mot) phong bi niem phong cua VBo Cl ben trong chua dia DVD chua du lieu vu tai nan giao thong. Xet day la tai lieu chirng minh hanh vi pham toi cua bi cao nen Co quan dieu tra da dira vao liru tru tai ho so vu an. Nen Hoi dong xet xir miem xet.

Doi vdi: 01 (Mot) xe mo to bien so 37X4 - 1867 mau den, do co so may VMVA2EH - 508086, so khung GSC10BH7H - 508086 xe da qua su dung va bi lnr hong do tai nan giao thong.. 01 (Mot) xe 6 to nhan hieu CNHTC, so loai ZZ4257   co so may:   WD61596E150317014237,  so khung:

LZZ5CLSB1FN076996 mau do, mang bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 xe da qua sir dung  keo theo so mi ro mooc nhan hieu CIMIC co so khung

LJRH13381FN032253 mang bien so 37R - 031.72 xe 6 to va so mi ro mooc deu da qua su dung.

Cac vat chirng neu tren la phirong tien trong vu tai nan giao thong, xet khong anh lnrdng den qua trinh giai quyet vu an nen Co quan CSDT Cong an huyen T tra lai tai san cho chu so hiru theo dung quy dinh, nen Hoi dong xet xu mien xet.

[7] Ve an phi: Ap dung khoan 2 Dieu 136 Bo luat to tung hinh sir; diem a khoan 1 Dieu 23 Nghi quyet 326/2016/UBTVQH14 ngay 30/12/2016 ve an phi, le phi Toa an, buoc bi cao phai chiu 200.000 dong tien an phi hinh sir so tham.

• * Doi vdi hanh vi Le Van H4 khien xe 6 to gay tai nan dan den anh Tran Van Hll thirong nhirng anh H2co don xin tir choi giam dinh ty le tlnrong tich nen khong co can cir xac dinh trach nhiem hinh sir doi vdi Le Van Hl6 hau qua thiet hai neu tren.

• * Doi vdi Tran Van H2dieu khien xe di chuyen tir dudng khong iru tien ra dirdng iru tien phai co trach nhiem nlnrdng dudng cho xe di tren dudng iru tien nhung T1 dieu khien xe qua ‘A nga tir thi chi phai nhudng dudng cho xe di tir hirbng ben phai den khong phai nhirbng cho xe di chuyen tir phia ben trai sang nen T2 co loi dan den vu tai nan. Do do, khong co can cu xir ly hinh sir doi vdi Tran Van Hl7

QUYET DINH

1- Can cu’: Diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260, diem b, s khoan 1, khoan 2 Dieu 51, Dieu 65 Bo luat hinh str:

Xu phat: Bi cao: L2 ( Ba miroi sau) thang til. Ve toi: “Vi pham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dirbng bo”, nhung cho hirbng an treo, thoi gian thu thach 60 ( Sau muoi) thang. Thoi han thu thach diroc tinh tir ngay tuyen an so tham. Mien hinh phat bo sung cho bi cao.

Giao bi cao Le Van H cho Uy ban nhan dan xa H, tinh Nghe Angiam sat, giao due trong thoi gian thu thach, gia dinh bi cao co trach nhiem phdi hop vdi Uy ban nhan xa H, huyen T, tinh Nghe Antrong viec giam sat, giao due bi cao trong thoi gian thu thach.

⁹

Truong hop ngudi duoc hirbng an treo thay doi noi cu tru thi phai thirc hien theo quy dinh tai khoan 3 Dieu 92 Luat thi hanh an hinh sir nam 2019.

Trong thoi gian thu thach, bi cao Le Van H duoc hubng an treo co y vi ' ⁹ '

pham nghia vu 02 lan trb len thi Toa an cd the quyet dinh buoc ngudi diroc hirbng an treo phai chap hanh hinh phat tu cua ban an da cho hirbng an treo.

• 3- Ve an phi: Ap dung Dieu 135, Dieu 136 BLTTHS; Nghi quyet 326/2016/UBTVQH14 ngay 30/12/2016 ve an phi, le phi Toa an, buoc bi cao Le Van H phai chiu 200.000 d tien an phi hinh sir so tham.

A             A                                     

• 4- Ve quyen khang cao: Trong han 15 ngay, ke tir ngay tuyen an, bi cao, ngudi dai dien hop phap cho bi hai va diroc uy quyen cua bi hai co mat tai phien toa, co quyen khang cao ban an len Toa an nhan dan tinh Nghe An. Bi hai

r                                                                                                           x

vang mat tai phien toa co quyen khang cao trong han 15 ngay ke tir ngay nhan 9

diroc ban sao ban an hoac ke tir ngay niem yet ban an.

HOI DONG XET XlT

THAM PHAN CHU TOA PHIEN TOA

TOA AN NHAN DAN

HUYEN TAN KY

TINH NGHE AN

BIEN BAN NGHI AN

Vao ngay 08 thang 5 nam 2024.

Tai: Phong nghi an Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky, tinh Nghe An. \                                        o           A

Hoi dong xet xu so' th am gom co:

Tham phan - Chu toa phien toa: Ong: DgngXuan H18.

Cac Hoi tham :

• 1. Ba : Nguyen Thi Van A.

• 2. Ba: Vu Thi T H4.

Tien hanh nghi an vu an hinh su so tham thu ly so: 41/2024/TLST-HS ngay 24 thang 4 nam 2024 doi vdi bi cao:

Ho va ten: Le Van H- Gidi tinh: Nam; Ten goi khac: Khong; Sinh ngay: 10/9/1976 tai huyen T, tinh Nghe An; Noi cu tru: Xom T, xa H, huyen T, Nghe An. Cd mat.

Cd/7 cuDieu 299 va Dieu 326 cua Bo luat To tung hinh str;

Can cu cac chung cu va tai lien da dupe xem xet tai phien toa, ket qua tranh tung tai phien toa, cac quy dinh cua phap luat

HOI DONG XET XL/ THAO LUAN, BIEU QUYET, QUYET DINH CAC VAN DE CUA VU AN NHU SAU:

• 1- Vu an khong thuoc trudng hop tarn dinh chi, khong thuoc trudng hop

y              9       y                 9

tra ho so de dieu tra bo sung.

Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

y                         y                                                         9

• 2- Nhung chung cu, tai lieu do co quan dieu tra, dieu tra vien, Vien kiem sat, bi can, bi cao cung cap dung vdi quy dinh cua phap luat.

Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

3. Tuyen bd bi cao: Te Van H pham toi: " Vi pham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dudng bo

Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

y                                                                                                                                    r

4- Ve hinh phat, cac bien phap tu phap ap dung ddi vdi cac bi cao: Can cu’: Diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260, diem b, s khoan 1, khoan 2 Dieu 51, Dieu 65 Bo luat hinh sir:

Xu phat: Bi cao: L2( Ba muoi sau) thang tu. Ve toi: “Vi pham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dudng bo”, nhung cho hudng an treo, thdi gian thu thach 60 ( Sau muoi) thang. Thdi han thu thach duoc tinh tu ngay tuyen an so tham. Mien hinh phat bo sung cho bi cao.

Giao bi cao Te Van H cho Uy ban nhan dan xa H, tinh Nghe Angiam sat, giao due trong thdi gian thu thach, gia dinh bi cao co trach nhiem phdi hop vdi Uy ban nhan xa H, huyen T, tinh Nghe Antrong viec giam sat, giao due bi cao trong thdi gian thu thach.

⁹ Truong hop nguoi duoc huong an treo thay doi noi cu tru thi phai thuc hien theo quy dinh tai khoan 3 Dieu 92 Luat thi hanh an hinh sir nam 2019.

Trong thdi gian thu thach, bi cao Le Van Hl9 huong an treo cd y vi pham nghia vu 02 lan trd len thi Toa an co the quyet dinh buoc nguoi duoc huong an treo phai chap hanh hinh phat tu cua ban an da cho huong an treo.

Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

• 5- Bi cao khong duoc mien trach nhiem hinh sir, mien hinh phat. Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

6. Ve trach nhiem dan sir, ve vat chirng, an phi hinh sir: A Ve track nhiem dan sir: Khong.

A Ve vat chirng vu an: Khong.

Ve phan an phi: Ap dung Dieu 135, Dieu 136 BLTTHS; Nghi quyet 326/2016/UBTVQH14 ngay 30/12/2016 ve an phi, le phi Toa an, buoc bi cao Le Van H14 chin 200.000 d tien an phi hinh sir so tham.Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

7- Trong qua trinh thuc hien hanh vi, quyet dinh to tung cua Dieu tra vien, 9

kiem sat vien dung voi nhirng quy dinh cua phap.

Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

\             \                                       r                                     o

8. Ve quyen khang cao doi voi ban an: Trong han 15 ngay, ke tu ngay tuyen an, bi cao, nguoi dai dien hop phap cho bi hai va duoc uy quyen cua bi hai co mat tai phien toa, cd quyen khang cao ban an len Toa an nhan dan tinh Nghe An. Bi hai vang mat tai phien toa co quyen khang cao trong han 15 ngay 9       or

ke tir ngay nhan duoc ban sao ban an hoac ke tu ngay niem yet ban an. Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

9- Kien nghi phong ngira toi pham, khac phuc vi pham: Khong. Ket qua bieu quyet: 3/3.

Nghi an ket thuc vao ngay 08 thang 5 nam 2024.

Bien ban nghi an da duoc doc lai cho tat ca cac thanh vien Hoi dong xet xir cung nghe va ky ten.

HOI DONG XET XlT

THAM PHAN CHU TOA PHIEN TOA

Dang Xuan H3

Not nhan:	T.M/ HOI DONG XET XU* •
- TAND tinh Nghe An; - So Tir phap; - Cong an huyen Tan Ky;	THAM PHAN - CHU TOA PHIEN TOA •

• - VKSND huyen Tan Ky;

• - Chi cue THADS Tan Ky;

• - Bi cao, bi hai

  Dang Xuan Hoan

=Ngudi dai dien hap phap cho bi hai

• - Luu ho so vu an;

* Vat chung cua vu an:

Qua trinh dieu tra, Co quan dieu tra thu giu gom:

• (1) 01 (Mot) phong bi niem phong cua VBo Cl ben trong chua dia DVD chua dir lieu vu tai nan giao thong. Xet day la tai lieu chirng minh hanh vi pham toi cua bi can nen Co quan dieu tra da dira vao luu tru tai ho so vu an.

• (2) 01 (Mot) xe mo to bien so 37X4 - 1867 mau den, do co so may VMVA2EH - 508086, so khung GSC10BH7H - 508086 xe da qua su dung va bi lnr hong do tai nan giao thong.

• (3) 01 (Mot) xe 6 to nhan hieu CNHTC, so loai ZZ4257 co so may: WD61596E150317014237, so khung: LZZ5CLSB1FN076996 mau do, mang

9           9

bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 xe da qua su dung keo theo so mi ro mooc nhan hieu CIMIC co so khung LJRH13381FN032253 mang bien so 37R - 031.72 xe 6 to va so mi ro mooc deu da qua su dung.

Cac vat chirng so (2) va (3) la plnrong tien trong vu tai nan giao thong, xet khong anh hubng den qua trinh giai quyet vu an nen Co quan canh sat dieu tra Cong an huyen T tra lai tai san cho chu sb him theo dung quy dinh. (But luc so: 136, 137 HSVA).

* Ve phan dan sir:

Bi can da thoa thuan, tir nguyen boi thubng thiet hai cho bi hai va gia dinh bi hai, vdi so tien: 250.000.000 dong (77az tram nam mucri trieu dong) nen cac bi hai khong co yeu cau gi them, dong thbi co don xin giam nhe hinh phat cho Le Van H(But luc so: 66- 71 HSVA).

r

Can cir vao cac tinh tiet va chirng cir neu tren,

KET LUAN

•

Vao khoang 12 gib 52 phut ngay 15/12/2022, Le Van H8 co giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh dieu khien xe 6 to, bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 keo theo so mi ro mooc, bien kiem soat: 37R - 031.72 cho go cay keo di chuyen tren dubng H hubng tir thi trail T hubng di huyen N, tinh Nghe An. Khi den Km 672 + 500 dubng H thuoc xom F, xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe An do khong lam chu toe do, y              9                                 y                                                                         \

dieu khien xe sang phan dubng cua xe di ngiroc chieu nen da dam true dien vao xe mo to, bien kiem soat: 37X4 - 1867 do anh Tran Van H9 khien cho theo chi Dao Thi Hl (La vo cua anh H2dang di chuyen tir ben phai qua ben trai dubng HHau qua: Chi Dao Thi Hl tir vong tren dubng di cap ciru; anh Tran Van Hll tlurong nang phai dira di cap ciru; Xe 6 to va xe mo to bi hu hong.

9 Nlnr vay, co du can cu de xac dinh bi can co ly lich dubi day da pham toi nlnr sau:

Ho va ten: Le Van H- Gibi tinh: Nam. Ten goi khac: Khong

Sinh ngay: 10/9/1976 tai huyen T, tinh Nghe An

Noi cir tru: Xom T, xa H, huyen T, Nghe An

Quoc tich: Viet Nam;Dan toe: Kinh; Ton giao: Khong; Nghe nghiep: Lai xe;

Chuc vu (Dang, chinh quyen, doan the): Khong;       Trinh do van hoa: 03/12.

Con ong: Le Van CSinh nam: 1950.

Con ba: Nguyen Thi LSinh nam: 1950.

Anh, chi, em ruot, gia dinh co 02 nguoi, bi can la con thir 02.

Vo: Tran Thi TSinh nam: 1978.

Con: Co 03 con, con Ion nhat 26 tuoi, con nho nhat 22 tuoi. Tien an, tien sir: Khong.

Bi can bi ap dung bien phap “Cam di khoi noi cir tru” tu ngay 28/01/2024 den nay tai dia phuong.

Hanh vi cua Le Van H10 vi pham khoan 9, khoan 23 Dieu 8; khoan 1 Dieu 9 Luat giao thong dirong bo nam 2008, sira doi nam 2019 nen da pham toi “Viphqm quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong ducrng bo ” quy dinh tai diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260 Bo luat Hinh sir.

Dieu 8 Luat giao thong duong bo quy dinh:

“Cdc hdnh vi bi cam:

\              9                                                             Z

9. Dieu khien xe ca gicri khong cd giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh;

23. Hdnh vi vi phqm quy tac giao thong ducrng bo, hdnh vi khac gay nguy hiem cho ngucri vdphuang tien tham gia giao thong”.

Dieu 9 Luat giao thong duong bo quy dinh:

“ Quy tac cluing:

• 1. Ngucri tham gia giao thong phdi di ben phdi theo chieu di cua mlnh, di dung Ian ducrng, phdn ducrng quy dinh vd phdi chap hdnh he thong bdo hieu ducrng bo ”.

Dieu 260 Bo luat Hinh sir quy dinh:

“7. Ngucri ndo tham gia giao thong ducrng bo ma vi phqm quy dinh ve an todn giao thong ducrng bo gay thiet hai cho ngucri khac thuoc mot trong cdc trucmg hap sail day, thi bi phat tien tie 30.000.000 dong den 100.000.000 dong, phat cai tqo khong giam giu den 03 nam hodc phat til tu 01 nam den 05 nam.

• a, LI chet ngucri.

• 2. Pham toi thuoc mot trong cdc trucmg hap san day, thi bi phat til tu 03 a dm den 10 nam:

a) Khong cd giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh;... ”.

• * Tinh tiet tang nang, giam nhe trach nhiem hinh sir:

• - Tinh tiet tang nang: Khdng.

• - Tinh tiet giam nhe: Ngudi pham toi tir nguyen boi thirdng thiet hai; Ngudi pham toi thanh khan khai bao, an nan hoi cai; Bo bi can la ngudi co cong vdi each mang diroc Nha nude tang thudng Huan chuong chien si ve vang; Dai dien ngudi bi hai co don xin giam nhe hinh phat - Quy dinh tai diem b, s khoan 1, khoan 2 Dieu 51 Bo luat Hinh sir.

• * Doi vdi hanh vi Le Van H4 khien xe o to gay tai nan dan den anh Tran Van Hll thirong nlnrng anh H2co don xin tir choi giam dinh ty le tlnrong tich nen khdng cd can cir xac dinh trach nhiem hinh sir doi vdi Le Van Hl6 han qua thiet hai neu tren.

• * Doi vdi Tran Van H2dieu khien xe di chuyen tir dudng khdng iru tien ra dirdng iru tien phai cd trach nhiem nlnrdng dudng cho xe di tren dudng iru tien nhung T1 dieu khien xe qua ‘A nga tir thi chi phai nhudng dudng cho xe di tir lnrdng ben phai den khdng phai nhudng cho xe di chuyen tir phia ben trai sang nen T2 cd loi dan den vu tai nan. Do do, khdng cd can cir xir ly hinh sir doi vdi Tran Van Hl7

QUYET DINH

• 1. Truy to ra tnrdc Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky, tinh Nghe An de xet xir bi can Le Van Hl6 toi “Vipham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dudng bo ” theo quy dinh tai diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260 Bo luat Hinh sir.

• 2. Kern theo Cao trang cd:

• - Ho so vu an gom cd: 08 tap .... trang, duoc danh so thir tir tir 01 den het;

9                       5                   r

• - Danh sach nhirng ngudi Vien kiem sat de nghi Toa an trieu tap den phien toa./.

  VIEN TRlTdNG

Neri nhan:

• - Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky;

• - Vien KSND tinh Nglie An (P2);

• - Ccr quan CSDT Cong an huyen;

• - Bi can;

  Nguyen Ngoc Manh

• - Luu: HSVA. HSKS./.

Noi dung ciia vu an da diroc bi cao khai bao rd rang, day du tai CQDT va 9          9           Z                                                                                    9

tai buoi tham van cong khai ngay horn nay cu the nhu sau: Vao khoang 12 gid 52 phut ngay 15/12/2022, Le Van H8 cd giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh dieu khien xe o to, bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 keo theo so mi ro mode, bien kiem soat: 37R - 031.72 cho go cay keo di chuyen tren dudng H hirdng tir thi tran T lnrdng di huyen N, tinh Nghe An. Khi den Km 672 + 500 dudng H thuoc xom F,

xa N, huyen T, tinh Nghe Ando khong lam chu toe do, dieu khien xe sang phan y                     99

dirong cua xe di ngugc chieu nen da dam true dien vao xe mo to, bien kiem soat: 37X4 - 1867 do anh Tran Van H9 khien cho theo chi Dao Thi Hl (La vg cua anh H2dang di chuyen tir ben phai qua ben trai dirong HHau qua: Chi Dao Thi Hl tir vong tren dirong di cap ciru; anh Tran Van Hll thuong nang phai dua di cap cuu; Xe 6 to va xe mo to bi hir hong.

Noi dung, dien bien hanh vi pham toi dirge phan anh qua Bien ban kham nghiem hien trudng, bien ban kham nghiem phirong tien gay tai nan, bien ban kham nghiem tir thi, loi khai cua nhirng ngudi lam chirng, dac biet la ldi khai nhan toi cua bi cao tai cac But luc so 153- 162 HSVA ve viec bi cao khong co giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh (hang FE) dieu khien xe khong lam chu toe do, khong di dung phan dirong, lan dirong dan den tai nan giao thong gay hau qua chet 01 ngirdi va bi thirong 01 ngirdi la phii hop vdi cac tai lieu, chirng cir khac '                                 ___ '                                    Z                     Z               9

co trong ho so vu an. Trong qua trinh dieu tra, tray to cho den budi xet xir ngay horn nay, Kiem sat vien nhan thay cac chirng cir buoc toi bi cao da dirge CQDT thu thap day du, toan dien, dung trinh tir, thu tuc theo quy dinh cua BLTTHS. Qua budi tham van cong khai tai phien toa ngay horn nay, bi cao da hoan toan thira nhan hanh vi pham toi cua minh va khong co khai nai gi them. Do do, Vien kiem sat tiny to bi cao Le Van H20 trade Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky ve hanh vi “Fz pham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dudng bo” theo quy dinh tai Khoan 2 Dieu 260 la hoan toan cd du can cir.

* Xet ve tinh chat, mire do, hau qua cua toi pham, thay ding: Tinh hinh vi 9          r                         9

pham trat tir an toan giao thong van xay ra thirong xuyen va pho bien, gay ton r                                                    \

that nghiem trgng ve tai san, sire khoe, tinh mang con ngirdi. Nguyen nhan xay ra tai nan giao thong chu yeu la chay qua toe do quy dinh, tranh virgt sai quy dinh, khong di dung phan dirong, lan dirong, thieu chu y quan sat nlnr hanh vi cua bi cao Le Van H10 thirc hien vao ngay 15/12/2022. Hon nua, hanh vi bi cao khong co giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh ma dieu khien phirong tien tham gia giao thong gay tai nan dan den hau qua chet ngudi thuoc trudng hgp quy dinh tai diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260 BLHS, co muc hinh phat len den 10 nam til nen hanh vi cua bi cao Le Van H12 toi thuoc trudng hgp rat nghiem trgng. Hanh vi do da true tiep xam hai den tinh mang cua bi hai chi Dao Thi H21 xam hai den than the cua anh Tran Van H22 vi cua bi cao the hien sir thieu y thirc chap hanh luat giao thong dirong bo, thieu y thirc bao ve an toan tinh mang, sire khoe cho chinh ban than bi cao va cho nhirng ngudi ciing tham gia giao thong. Vu tai nan do bi cao gay ra da tube doat tinh mang cua mot ngudi vg, ngudi me cua gia dinh, gay di tat suot ddi cho anh Tran Van H23 la noi dau va sir mat mat kho co the bu dap trgn ven. Dong thdi con tac dong tieu cue den nd luc cua cac cap, cac nganh

r                                                   9           r

trong viec khac phuc, giam thieu so luong va hau qua cac vu tai nan giao thong tai dia ban huyen T

• * Xet ve nhan than va vai tro cua bi cao trong vu an, thay rang: Bi cao Le Van H10 trai qua dao tao, sat hach va diroc cap giay phep lai xe hang C nen da diroc trang bi kien thuc ve dam bao an toan khi tham gia giao thong dudng bo; tai thdi diem toi pham xay ra bi cao co day du kha nang nhan thuc, kha nang dieu khien hanh vi de danh gia va lira chon hanh vi phu hop. Tuy nhien, y thuc

r                                                                                                                                             \

chap hanh luat giao thong dudng bo cua bi cao con kem, dieu khien phuong tien khi khong co giay phep lai xe theo quy dinh, khong lam chu toe do, di khong dung lan dudng, phan dudng theo quy dinh gay tai nan giao thong dan den chi Dao Thi H24 vong va anh Tran Van Hll thirong. Ve mat loi, toi pham diroc thuc hien vdi loi vd y, do bi cao khong chap hanh nghiem cac quy tac giao thong dudng bo nen xay ra tai nan giao thong dan den hau qua chet ngudi xay ra.

Do do, horn nay Toa an nhan dan huyen Tan Ky dira ra xet xu cong khai vu an doi vdi bi cao Le Van H25 Vien kiem sat nhan dan huyen Tan Ky truy to ve toi “Vi pham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dudng bo” la viec lam can thiet, phu hop vdi mong muon cua quan chung nhan dan va cac quy dinh cua phap luat de toi pham phai diroc phat hien, xu ly kip thdi va nghiem minh.

Bi cao Le Van H8 co tinh tiet tang nang trach nhiem hinh sir. Qua trinh dieu tra, bi cao da thanh khan khai bao; sau khi xay ra tai nan dan den chi Dao Thi Hl5 vong bi cao da kip thdi tham hoi, dong vien, boi thirong cho gia dinh bi hai nen duoc dai dien gia dinh bi hai viet don xin giam nhe hinh phat. Vi vay, bi cao duoc hudng cac tinh tiet giam nhe trach nhiem hinh sir quy dinh tai diem b, s khoan 1, khoan 2 Dieu 51 BLHS.

Xet thay, bi cao Le Van H12 toi rat nghiem trong vdi loi vd y nhirng ban r                                                                            r

than bi cao cd nhan than tot, bi cao khong cd tinh tiet tang nang va duoc hudng nhieu tinh tiet giam nhe nen chira can thiet each ly bi cao ra khoi doi song xa hoi, ma can giao bi cao cho chinh quyen dia phuong giam sat, giao due cung du 9

nghiem, de bi cao cd co hoi d ngoai xa hoi cai tao, tu dudng tro thanh ngudi cong dan tot cho gia dinh va xa hoi, dong thdi tao dieu kien bi cao lao dong nuoi day con tre nham the hien tinh khoan hong cua phap luat xa hoi chu nghia.

Qua nghien cuu cac tai lieu chung cir cd trong ho so vu an trong suot giai doan dieu tra, tiny to cho den loi khai nhan cua bi cao tai phien toa ngay horn nay cd du can cu de khang dinh Ban Cao trang so 34/CT-VKS-TK ngay 04/4/2024 truy to bi cao Le Van Hl6 hanh vi “Tz pham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong dudng bo” theo quy dinh tai diem a Khoan 2 Dieu 260 Bo luat Hinh sir la dung ngudi, dung toi, dam bao dung quy dinh phap luat.

• * Vat chung cua vu an:

• (1) 01 (Mot) phong bi niem phong cua VBo Cl ben trong chira dia DVD chua dir lieu vu tai nan giao thong. Xet day la tai lieu chung minh hanh vi pham toi cua bi can nen Co quan dieu tra da dua vao liru tru tai ho so vu an nen de nghi HDXX mien xet.

• (2) 01 (Mot) xe mo to bien so 37X4 - 1867 mau den, do cd sb may VMVA2EH - 508086, so khung GSC10BH7H - 508086 xe da qua su dung va bi lnr hong do tai nan giao thong.

• (3) 01 (Mot) xe 6 to nhan hieu CNHTC, sb loai ZZ4257 co sb may: WD61596E150317014237, so khung: LZZ5CLSB1FN076996 mau do, mang

9           9

bien kiem soat: 37H - 014.19 xe da qua sir dung keo theo so mi ro mooc nhan hieu CIMIC co so khung LJRH13381FN032253 mang bien so 37R - 031.72 xe o to va so mi ro mooc deu da qua sir dung.

Cac vat chung sb (2) va (3) la plnrong tien trong vu tai nan giao thdng, xet khong anh hirong den qua trinh giai quyet vu an nen Co quan canh sat dieu tra Cong an huyen T tra lai tai san cho chu so huu theo dung quy dinh nen de nghi HDXX mien xet.

* Ve phan dan sir:

Bi can da thoa thuan, tir nguyen boi thirbng thiet hai cho gia dinh bi hai anh Tran Van H26 so tien: 250.000.000 dong (Hai tram nam mucri trieu dong) nen gia dinh bi hai khong co yeu cau gi them, dong thbi co don xin giam nhe hinh phat cho H27 de nghi HDXX mien xet.

• * Ve hinh phat bo sung: Tai khoan 5 Dieu 260 BLHS quy dinh: “Ngud'i pham toi con cd the bi cam dam nhiem chtrc vu, cam hanh nghe hoqc lam cdng viec nhdt dinh tir 01 nam den 05 nam Qua xac minh, bi cao khong dam nhiem chuc vu hay hanh nghe trong mot linh virc nhat dinh nao nen mien hinh phat bo sung cho bi cao.

_                                                                          _                  *7                                         a            r

Tren co* so* phan tich danh gia nhir tren, Kiem sat vien de xuat quan *9

diem xir lv nhu sau:

•/

• a, Ve trach nhiem hinh sir: Tuyen bo Le Van H12 toi “Vipham quy dinh ve tham gia giao thong ducmg bo

• * Hinh phat chinh: Ap dung diem a khoan 2 Dieu 260, diem b, s khoan 1, khoan 2 Dieu 51, Dieu 65 BLHS xir phat Le Van H13 an 36 thang tu, cho hubng

9 an treo, thbi gian thu thach 60 thang, ke tir ngay tuyen an so tham.

- Hinh phat bd sung:

• b, Trach nhiem dan sir: Khong.

• c, Xir ly vat chung: Khong.

• d, Ve an phi: Ap dung khoan 2 Dieu 136 BLTTHS; diem a khoan 1 Dieu 23 Nghi quyet 326/2016/UBTVQH14 ngay 30/12/2016 ve an phi, le phi Toa an, buoc bi cao Le Van H14 chiu 200.000 dong tien an phi HSST

Tren day la quan diem cua Vien kiem sat ve viec xu ly doi voi bi cao va giai quyet vu an tai phien toa horn nay, de nghi HDXX xem xet va quyet dinh ban an dung ngudi, dung toi, dung phap luat nham giao due, ran de doi voi bi cao dong thdi gop phan vao cong tac phong ngira chung.

KIEM SAT VIEN

Nguyen Van Dan

- 24-