TOA AN NHAN DAN CAP CAO TAI THANH PHO HO CHI MINH
CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM Doc lap - Tu do - Hanh phuc
Ban an so: 18/2024/HNGD-PT
Ngay: 04-6-2024
“N/v ly lion va chia tai san khi ly hon”.
NHAN DANH
NUOC CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM • • •
TOA AN NHAN DAN CAP CAO TAI THANH PHO HO CHI MINH
-
- Thanh phan Hoi dong xet xu phuc tham gom co:
9 K
Tham phan - Chii toa phien toa: Ong Nguyen Van Khuong.
Cac tham phan: Ba Nguyen Thi Thuy Vu
Ong Tran Van Muoi
-
- Thu ky phien toa: Ba Dinh Thi Thanh Binh - Thu ky Toa an nhan dan cap cao tai Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh.
-
- Dai (lien Tien kiem sat nhan dan cap cao tai Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh: Ba Pham Thi Thanh Hoa - Kiem sat vien.
Trong cac ngay 29 thang 5 den ngay 04 thang 6 nam 2024, tai tru so Toa an nhan dan cap cao tai Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh mb phien toa xet xu cong khai vu an Hon nhan va gia dinh phuc tham thu ly so: 07/2024/TLPT-HNGD ngay 04 thang 3 nam 2024 ve viec “Ly hon va chia tai san khi ly hon”.
Do Ban an Hon nhan va gia dinh so tham so: 38/2023/HNGD-ST ngay 21-11-2023 cua Toa an nhan dan tinh Binh Duong bi khang cao.
Theo Quyet dinh dua vu an ra xet xu so: 1425/2024/QDXXPT- HNGD ngay 15 thang 5 nam 2024, giua cac duong sir:
-
- Nguyen don: Ba Phan Kim H, sinh nam 1952; dia chi: C Vantage S (co van ban yeu cau giai quyet vang mat).
Ngucri dai dien theo uy quyen ve tranh chap tai san cua nguyen dan: Ong Nguyen Huu Hl, sinh nam 1983; dia chi: so D, Dai 16 B, phubng P, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong (van ban uy quyen ngay 06/6/2018) va ba Tran Thi Nhu M, sinh nam 1994; dia chi: F V, Phuong C, quan B, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh (van ban uy quyen ngay 15/02/2020) (co mat).
/a r
-
- Bi cion: Ong Vuong Anh D, sinh nam 1952; dia chi: so D, dudng
N, khu dan cu T, phuong A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong (chet ngay 16/6/2020).
Ngud'i ke thira quyen, nghia vu to tung cua ong D:
___' ' '
-
1. Ong Vuong Tan S, sinh nam 1929; dia chi: ap A, phuong A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong (vang mat).
-
2. Ba Vuong Hoang T, sinh nam 1976; dia chi: C W P, A, CA 92801 r
(vang mat).
-
3. Ong Vuong Phan Phu C, sinh nam 1978; dia chi: A W, W, CA 92683 r
(vang mat).
-
4. Ong Vuong Phan Phu SI, sinh nam 1980; dia chi: A V, S, CA 90680 r
(vang mat).
-
5. Ong Vuong Huy L, sinh nam 1986; dia chi: ap A, xa T, huyen C, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh (vdng mat).
A /A
Ngtrai dqi dien theo uy quyen cua dug L: Ong Vuong Huy P, sinh nam 1987; dia chi: ap A, xa T, huyen C, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh (co mat).
-
6. Ong Vuong Huy P, sinh nam 1987; dia chi: A, ap A, xa T, huyen C, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh (co mat).
A
• z\
-
- Nguoi co quyen loi, nghia vu lien quan:
-
1. Ba Nguyen Thi DI, sinh nam 1977; dia chi: khu pho C, thi tran C, huyen C, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong (vang mat).
A /A
Ngirai bdo ve quyen va loi ich hop phap cua ba DI: Ong Luu Van B - Luat su Van phong LI thuoc Doan Luat su tinh L (vang mat).
-
2. Ba Nguyen Thi Thanh Tl, sinh nam 1985; dia chi: phuong Y, quan H, Thanh pho Ha Noi (vang mat).
-
3. Ba Nguyen Thi Bao N, sinh nam 1981; dia chi: ap A, phuong A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong (vang mat).
-
4. Cong ty Co phan T2; dia chi: so F dudng L, phuong L, thanh pho T, Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh.
/A
Ngicoi dqi dien theo phap luat cua cong ty: Ong Bui Van Q, sinh nam 1973; dia chi: khoi A, dudng Q, thanh pho V, tinh Nghe An, chuc vu: Tong giam r r
doc (vang mat).
A /A
Ngirdi dqi dien diro'c ong Bui Van Q uy quyen: Ong Nguyen Minh H2 - Pho phong phap che cua Cong ty Co phan T2 (co mat).
Nguoi co khang cao: ong Vuong Huy P la nguoi ke thira quyen, nghia vu to tung cua bi don khang cao va ong Nguyen Huu Hl la nguoi duoc nguyen don uy quyen khang cao.
• •
Nguyen dan ba Phan Kim H trinh bay:
-
- Ve quan he lion nhan: Ba H va ong Vuong Anh D (chet ngay 16/6/2020) to chuc dam cubi va song chung nhu vo chong tu thang 6 nam 1976. Den ngay 10/01/1984 moi di dang ky ket lion va duoc Uy ban nhan dan xa A, huyen T, tinh Song Be (nay la phubng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong) cap giay chung nhan dang ky ket lion so 30. Qua trinh song chung, vo chong thubng xuyen xay ra mau thuan bat hoa do co sir khac biet ve loi song, vo chong thieu ton trong lan nhau. Nam 1996, ba H xuat canh sang Hoa Ky sinh song cho den nay. Do khong cung tieng noi chung nen vo chong ngay cang xa each, khong quan tarn lan nhau. Do vay, ba H co don khoi kien ly lion ong D.
-
- Ve con chung: Qua trinh song chung, ba H va ong D co 03 ngirbi con chung gom ba Vuong Hoang T, sinh nam 1976, ong Vuong Phan Phu Cl, sinh nam 1978, ong Vuong Phan Phu SI, sinh nam 1980. Hien 03 ngirbi con chung nay dang sinh song tai Hoa Ky va da trubng thanh nen ba H khong yeu cau Toa
t , r
an giai quyet.
-
- Ve tai san chung: Ba H yeu cau Toa an chia tai san chung cua vo chong trong thbi ky lion nhan giua ba H va ong D bao gom:
-
1. Dien tich dat 554,5m2 thuoc thua dat 334 va dien tich dat 3.943m2 thuoc thua dat 90, cung to ban do so 178, toa lac tai khu pho A, phubng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong theo Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so 01046 QSDD/AP do UBND huyen (nay la thanh pho ) T, tinh Binh Duong cap cho ong Vuong Anh D ngay 06/4/2001.
-
2. 14 Quyen su dung dat dung ten ong Vuong Anh D do UBND huyen D, tinh Dak Nong cap cho ong D gom cac Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so AG822941, AG822942, AG822054, AL045964, AN064075, AN064076, AN064078, AG822430, AG822940, AG822053, BC813162, BC813160, BA165100, AL045965 va Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so AN951611 do UBND tinh D cap cho Doanh nghiep tu nhan Pl ngay 09/12/2008.
-
3. Can nha so G va 43/DC4 khu dan cir A, phubng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong.
-
4. Huy Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen su dung dat so 1482 ngay 23/7/2018 giua ong Vuong Anh D vbi ba Nguyen Thi DI do Van phong C2 cong chung va huy Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen su dung dat so 15883 ngay 23/11/2018 giua ba Nguyen Thi DI vbi ba Nguyen Thi Thanh T1 do Van phong cong chung Nguyen Thi G cong chung.
Ba H yeu cau duoc nhan 50% tai san bang gia tri.
Bi dan ong Vuong Anh D trinh bay (Tai Van ban trinh bay ngay 20/12/2018, ban tu khai ngay 15/7/2019): Thbi diem ong D con song thi ong D da co y kien trinh bay doi vbi yeu cau khoi kien cua ba H. Ong D dong y ly lion
ba H, con chung da tnrdng thanh nen khong yeu cau giai quyet, con ve tai san chung thi ong D khong dong y vdi yeu cau khdi kien cua ba H vi thira dat 334 va < \ r ' r
thira dat 90, cung to ban do so 178, toa lac tai khu pho A, phudng A, thanh pho
T, tinh Binh Duong theo Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so 01046
QSDD/AP do UBND huyen (nay la thanh pho ) T, tinh Binh Duong cap cho ong
Vuong Anh D ngay 06/4/2001 la tai san do cha ruot cua ong D la ong Vuong Tan S cho rieng ong D va tai Ban an so tham so 96/2018/DSST ngay 15/8/2017 cua TAND thi xa Thuan An (nay la thanh pho T) va Ban an phuc tham so 13/2018/DSPT ngay 15/01/2018 cua TAND tinh Binh Duong cung da xac dinh day la tai san do cha cua ong D cho rieng ong D, vi vay khong phai la tai san chung cua ong D vdi ba H. Doi vdi nhung tai san khac ma ong D dung ten thi ong D khong dong y vdi yeu cau phan chia tai san chung vi ba H da qua Hoa Ky sinh song tir lau nen ba H cung khong co dong gop cong sue gi ma tai san do tu ong D lam an, kinh doanh ma co dirge nen khong phai la tai san chung giira ong D vdi ba H.
Nhung nguai ke thira quyen va nghia vu to tung cua dug D trinh bay:
-
1. Ong Vuong Tan S trinh bay: Ong la cha mot cua ong D. Thira dat 334
r \ r r
va thua dat 90, cung to ban do so 178, toa lac tai khu pho A, phudng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong la cua ong S cho rieng ong D, la tai san rieng cua ong D, khong lien quan gi den ba H. Ong S khong dong y vdi yeu cau khdi kien cua ba H.
-
2. Ba Vuong Hoang T, ong Vuong Phan Phu C, ong Vuong Phan Phu SI thong nhat trinh bay: Ba T, ong C, ong SI la con ruot cua ba H va ong D. Nhung tai san tai Viet Nam do ong D dung ten deu la tai san chung cua ong D vdi ba H. Ba T, ong C, ong SI khong co cong sue dong gop va lien quan gi.
-
3. Ong Vuong Huy L, ong Vuong Huy P thong nhat trinh bay: Ong L va ong P la con mot cua ong D vdi ba Nguyen Thi V. Thua dat 334 va thua dat 90, cung to ban do so 178, toa lac tai khu pho A, phudng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh
f \
Duong la cua ong D, khong lien quan gi den ba H. Ong L va ong P khong dong y vdi yeu cau khdi kien cua ba H.
Nguai cd quyen lai, nghia vu lien quan ba Nguyen Thi Bao N trinh bay: Ba N chi nhap nhd ho khau. Tai san ma cac duong sir tranh chap thi ba N khong co lien quan gi den va xin dirge giai quyet vang mat.
Ngucri bao ve quyen va lai ich hap phap cua ba Nguyen Thi DI: Luat su Luu Van B khong co y kien trong qua trinh giai quyet vu an.
Nguai Bai dien theo phap luat ciia Cong ty Co phan T2: Ong Bui Van Q khong co y kien trong qua trinh giai quyet vu an.
Nguai cd quyen lai, nghia vu lien quan ba Nguyen Thi Thanh T1 khong cd y kien trong qua trinh giai quyet vu an.
Tai Ban an Hon nhan va gia dinh so tham so: 38/2023/HNGD-ST ngay
21-11-2023 cua Toa an nhan dan tinh Binh Duong, da tuyen xir:
-
1. Dinh chi mot phan yeu cau khdi kien cua ba Phan Kim H doi vdi ngudi
'Ar ' '
ke thira quyen va nghia vu to tung cua ong Vuong Anh D gom: ong Vuong Tan S, ba Vuong Hoang T, ong Vuong Phan Phu C, ong Vuong Phan Phu SI, ong Vuong Huy L, ong Vuong Huy P doi vdi yeu cau chia tai san chung la 14 quyen sir dung dat dung ten ong Vuong Anh D do UBND huyen D, tinh Dak Nong cap cho ong D gom cac Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so AG822941, AG822942, AG822054, AL045964, AN064075, AN064076, AN064078, AG822430, AG822940, AG822053, BC813162, BC813160, BA165100, AL045965; Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so AN951611 do UBND tinh D cap cho Doanh nghiep tu nhan Pl ngay 09/12/2008 va 02 Can nha so G va 43/DC4 khu dan cu A, phudng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong.
-
2. Khong chap nhan yeu cau khdi kien cua ba Phan Kim H doi vdi ngudi ke thira quyen va nghia vu to tung cua ong Vuong Anh D gom: ong Vuong Tan S, ba Vuong Hoang T, ong Vuong Phan Phu C, ong Vuong Phan Phu SI, ong
f x a
Vuong Huy L, ong Vuong Huy P doi vdi yeu cau chia tai san chung la: quyen sir dung dat dien tich dat 554,5m2 thuoc thira dat 334 va dien tich dat 3.943m2 thuoc thira dat 90, ciing to ban do so 178, toa lac tai khu pho A, phudng A, ' ___ _ __ F X F F
thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong theo Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so 01046 QSDD/AP do UBND huyen (nay la thanh pho ) T, tinh Binh Duong cap cho ong Vuong Anh D ngay 06/4/2001.
F X F
-
3. Khong chap nhan yeu cau khdi kien ciia ba Phan Kim H doi vdi ngudi ke thira quyen va nghia vu to tung ciia ong Vuong Anh D gom: ong Vuong Tan S, ba Vuong Hoang T, ong Vuong Phan Phu C, ong Vuong Phan Phil SI, ong Vuong Huy L, ong Vuong Huy P ve viec yeu cau huy Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat so 1482 ngay 23/7/2018 giua ong Vuong Anh D vdi ba Nguyen Thi DI do Van phong C2 cong chung va huy Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat so 15883 ngay 23/11/2018 giua ba Nguyen Thi DI vdi ba Nguyen Thi Thanh T1 do Van phong cong chung Nguyen Thi G cong chung.
Ngoai ra, Ban an so tham con quyet dinh ve chi phi to tung, an phi va quyen khang cao.
Ngay 30/11/2023, ong Vuong Huy P la ngudi ke thira quyen, nghia vu to tung cua bi don khang cao de nghi huy Ban an so tham.
Ngay 30/11/2023, ong Nguyen Him Hl la ngudi duoc nguyen don uy quyen khang cao de nghi huy mot phan Ban an so tham.
Tai phien toa phuc tham:
FX A
Ong P va ong Hl giu nguyen yeu cau khang cao.
Dai dien Vien Kiem sat nhan dan cap cao tai Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh: /A A 9
Ong P va ong Hl khang cao de nghi huy ban an so tham nhung khong dua ra duoc can cu huy an, nen de nghi Hoi dong xet xir khong chap nhan yeu cau
khang cao, giu nguyen Ban an so tham.
• • \ 9
Sau khi nghien cuu cac tai lieu co trong ho so vu an diroc tham tra tai phien r 9 9
toa va can cir vao ket qua tranh luan tai phien toa, phat bieu cua Kiem sat vien va ngubi tham gia to tung, Hoi dong xet xu xet khang cao cua ong Vuong Huy P va khang cao cua ong Nguyen Him Hl, nhir sau:
-
* Ve to tung:
-
[1] . Tai phien toa, ngubi ke thira quyen va nghia vu to tung cua bi don gom ong Vuong Tan S, ba Vuong Hoang T, ong Vuong Phan Phu C, ong Vuong Phan Phu SI, ong Vuong Huy L va nhung ngubi co quyen loi va nghia vu lien quan vang mat. Can cu cac khoan 3 Dieu 296 cua Bo luat To tung dan sir, Hoi dong xet xu xet xir vang mat cac duong sir neu tren.
-
[2] . Nguyen don yeu cau huy Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat so 1482 ngay 23/7/2018 giira ong Vuong Anh D vbi ba Nguyen Thi DI do Van phong C2 cong chirng va Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat so 15883 ngay 23/11/2018 giua ba Nguyen Thi DI vbi ba Nguyen Thi Thanh T1 do Van phong cong chirng Nguyen Thi G cong chirng. Nhung Toa an cap so
9 r r
tham khong dira cac van phong cong chirng tren vao tham gia to tung la co thieu sot. Tuy nhien, viec khong dira Van phong cong chirng Doan Xuan H3 va Van phong cong chirng Nguyen Thi G vao tham gia gia vu an vbi tu each la ngubi co quyen loi, nghia vu lien quan khong lam anh lnrbng den quyen va loi ich cua cac duong sir trong vu an. Bbi le, tai Quyet dinh so 131/QD-VP CQCSDT ngay 11/12/2022 va Ket luan so 177/KL-VP CQCSDT ngay 11/12/2022 cua Co quan Canh sat Dieu tra Cong an tinh B; Thong bao so 28/TB-VKSBD-P1 ngay 31/3/2023 cua Vien tnrbng Vien Kiem sat nhan dan tinh Binh Duong deu xac dinh cac hop dong tren khong co dau hieu lam gia nen khong khbi to vu an hinh sir.
-
* Ve noi dung:
-
[3] . Doi vbi 14 Quyen sir dung dat dung ten ong Vuong Anh D do UBND
huyen D, tinh Dak Nong cap cho ong D (sau day viet tat: GCNQSDD) gom: GCNQSDD x x x --------
so AG822941; GCNQSDD so: GCNQSDD so: AG822054; GCNQSDD so: AL045964; GCNQSDD so: AN064076; GCNQSDD so: AG822430; GCNQSDD so: AG822940; GCNQSDD so: BC813162; GCNQSDD so: BA165100; GCNQSDD so: AL045965.
so: AG822942;
GCNQSDD so: so: AN064078; GCNQSDD so: so: BC813160; GCNQSDD so:
GCNQSDD
AN064075;
GCNQSDD
AG822053;
GCNQSDD
AN951611 do UBND tinh D cap cho Doanh nghiep tu nhan Pl ngay 09/12/2008 va 02 can nha so G va 43/DC4 khu dan cu A, phubng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong, nguyen don ba Phan Kim H yeu cau chia va ong Vuong Huy P la ngubi ke thira quyen, nghia vu to tung cua bi don va ong Nguyen Huu Hl la ngubi diroc nguyen don uy quyen khang cao de nghi chia cho ba H. Nhung ba H, ong
P va ong Hl khong ciing cap diroc cho Toa an cac tai lieu, chung cu la cac giay chirng nhan quyen sir dung dat, quyen so him nha neu tren. Toa an cung ra thong bao yeu cau ba H cung cap tai lieu, chung cu nhung ba H khong cung cap diroc. Chi nhanh Van phong dang ky dat dai thanh pho T cung khong tim thay thong tin nao lien quan den Can nha so G va 43/DC4 khu dan cu A, phirdng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong. Toa an nhan dan tinh Binh Duong co uy thac cho Toa an nhan dan huyen Dak R'Lap, tinh Dak Nong tien hanh bien phap thu thap chung cu voi cac tai lieu, chung cu lien quan den 14 giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat neu tren nhung khong thu thap diroc. Do do, Toa an cap so tham da dinh chi giai quyet doi voi yeu cau tren cua nguyen don va tuyen khi co cac tai lieu, chung cu thi nguyen don diroc quyen khdi kien trong mot vu an khac, la phu hop voi quy dinh tai diem b khoan 1 Dieu 192 Bo luat Td tung dan sir.
-
[4] . Doi voi yeu cau cua nguyen don yeu cau chia dien tich dat 554,5m2 thuoc thira dat 334 va dien tich dat 3.943m2 thuoc thira dat 90, cung td ban do so
z r r
178, toa lac tai khu pho A, plurdng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong theo Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so 01046 QSDD/AP do UBND huyen (nay la thanh pho ) T, tinh Binh Duong cap cho ong Vuong Anh D ngay 06/4/2001. Tai Ban an so tham so 96/2018/DSST ngay 15/8/2017 cua TAND thi xa Thuan An (nay la thanh pho T) va Ban an phuc tham so 13/2018/DSPT ngay 15/01/2018 cua Toa an nhan dan tinh Binh Duong da xac dinh cac tai san tren co nguon goc: Ngay 10/02/1986, ong D duoc cha ruot la cu Vuong Tan S tang cho rieng. Can cu diem b khoan 1 Dieu 92 Bo luat To tung dan sir nhung tinh tiet, su kien neu tren da co ban an co hieu lire phap luat nen khong phai chung minh.
-
[5] . Doi voi yeu cau cua nguyen don yeu cau huy Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen su dung dat so: H 1482 ngay 23/7/2018 giua ong Vuong Anh D voi ba Nguyen Thi DI do Van phong C2 cong chung va huy Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat so: 15883 ngay 23/11/2018 giua ba Nguyen Thi DI voi ba Nguyen Thi Thanh T1 do Van phong cong chung Nguyen Thi G cong
9 A
chung. Cac tai san chuyen nhuong trong cac hop dong nay la tai san rieng cua ong D nen viec ong D dinh doat la dung quy dinh cua phap luat. Ba H khong chung minh diroc co cong sue dong gop gi doi voi tai san neu tren nen Toa an so tham khong chap nhan yeu cau chia cac tai san nay cho ba H la co can cu.
-
[6] . Ong Nguyen Huu Hl la ngudi diroc nguyen don uy quyen khang cao cho rang, Ban an dan sir so tham so: 96/2017/DSST ngay 15-8-2017 cua Toa an nhan dan thi xa Thuan An va Don xin dang ky cap giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat ngay 09/6/2000, ong D co xac dinh: Thira dat so 90 va thira so 334 la
A 9
tai san chung ciia vo chong. Qua xem xet Ban an dan sir so tham neu tren (But luc 49), va Don xin dang ky cap giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat ngay 09/6/2000 (But luc 137 va Don xin ke khai nguon goc dat ngay 09/6/2000 (But luc 138) thi the hien noi dung: 02 thira dat neu tren ong D diroc cha ruot la ong r r
Virong Tan S tang cho, nen ldi trinh bay tren cua ong Hl khong co can cu chap nhan.
-
[7] . Doi vbi Ban an dan su so tham so: 96/2017/DSST ngay 15-8-2017 cua Toa an nhan dan thi xa Thuan An va Ban an dan su phuc tham so: 13/2018/DSPT ngay 15-01-2018 cua Toa an nhan dan tinh Binh Duong da co hieu luc phap luat, ong Nguyen Huu Hl la ngubi duoc nguyen don uy quyen khang cao cho rang, 02 ban an nay co vi pham nghiem trong thu tuc to tung do khong dua ba Phan Kim H vao tham gia to tung la ngubi co quyen, loi nghia vu lien quan. Truong hop neu ba H co can cu cho rang 02 ban an nay co vi pham thu tuc to tung thi ba H co quyen gui don khieu nai den Chanh an Toa an nhan
r *> r *>
dan toi cao hoac Vien trubng Vien kiem sat nhan toi cao de duoc xem xet theo thu tuc giam doc tham hoac tai tham doi vbi 02 ban an neu tren.
-
[8] . Nhu vay, Toa an cap so tham khong chap nhan yeu cau khbi kien cua nguyen don ba Phan Kim H ve chia tai san chung khi ly lion la co can cu, dung
zx r \ r
phap luat. Ong Vuong Huy P la ngubi ke thua quyen, nghia vu to tung cua bi don va ong Nguyen Huu Hl la ngubi duoc nguyen don uy quyen khang cao de nghi huy ban an so tham la khong co can cu chap nhan.
-
[9] . Dai dien Vien Kiem sat nhan dan cap cao tai Thanh pho Ho Chi Minh de nghi Hoi dong xet xu khong chap nhan yeu cau khang cao, giu nguyen Ban an so tham la co can cu.
' 9
-
[10] . An phi dan su phuc tham: Nguyen don ba H la ngubi cao tuoi, co
o zx
don xin mien an phi nen khong phai chiu an phi phuc tham; Ong Vuong Huy P r x r *>
la ngubi ke thua quyen, nghia vu to tung cua bi don phai chiu an phi phuc tham.
-
[11] . Cac quyet dinh khac cua Ban an so tham khong co khang cao, khong bi khang nghi co hieu luc phap luat ke tu ngay het thbi han khang cao, khang nghi.
Vi cac le tren,
Can cu khoan 1 Dieu 308 cua Bo luat To tung dan su. r ' _ 9
Khong chap nhan khang cao de nghi huy Ban an so tham cua ong Vuong Huy P la ngubi ke thua quyen, nghia vu to tung cua bi don va khang cao cua ong Nguyen Huu Hl la ngubi duoc nguyen don uy quyen.
Giu nguyen Ban an Hon nhan va gia dinh so tham so: 38/2023/HNGD-ST ngay 21-11-2023 cua Toa an nhan dan tinh Binh Duong.
Can cu diem b khoan 1 Dieu 92; Diem b khoan 1 Dieu 192 cua Bo luat To tung dan su; Dieu 65 cua Luat Hon nhan va gia dinh nam 2014; Dieu 166, 167 cua Luat Dat dai nam 2013; cac Dieu: 163, 164, 169, 181 195, 197 cua Bo luat Dan su nam 2005; cac Dieu: 116, 117, 119,158, 161, 192, 205 206 cua Bo luat Dan su nam 2015; Nghi quyet 326/2016/UBTVQH14 ngay 30 thang 12 nam 2016 cua Uy ban Thubng vu Quoc hoi quy dinh ve muc thu, mien, giam, thu, nop, quan ly va su dung an phi va le phi Toa an.
Tuyen xu:
-
1. Dinh chi mot phan yeu cau khdi kien cua ba Phan Kim H yeu cau chia
r yr
tai san chung doi vdi 14 quyen su dung dat dung ten ong Vuong Anh D do UBND huyen D, tinh Dak Nong cap cho ong D, gom: Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AG822941, Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so: AG822942, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AG822054, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AL045964, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AN064075, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AN064076, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AN064078, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AG822430, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AG822940, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: AG822053, Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so: BC813162, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: BC813160, Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so: BA165100, Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so: AL045965, Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so: AN951611 do UBND tinh D cap cho Doanh nghiep tu nhan Pl ngay 09/12/2008 va 02 Can nha so G va 43/DC4 khu dan cu A, phudng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong. Ba Phan Thi Kim H4 co quyen khdi kien lai khi cung cap duoc chung cu.
-
2. Khong chap nhan yeu cau khdi kien cua ba Phan Kim H4 doi vdi yeu cau chia tai san chung doi vdi dien tich dat 554,5m2 thuoc thua dat 334 va dien tich dat 3.943m2 thuoc thua dat 90, cung td ban do so 178, toa lac tai khu pho A, phudng A, thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong (dat da duoc cap Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so 01046 QSDD/AP do Uy ban nhan dan thanh pho T, tinh Binh Duong cap cho ong Vuong Anh D ngay 06/4/2001).
-
3. Khong chap nhan yeu cau khdi kien cua ba Phan Kim H4 doi vdi yeu cau huy 02 Hop dong: Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat so: 1482 ngay 23/7/2018 giua ong Vuong Anh D vdi ba Nguyen Thi DI do Van phong
y 9 y r r
C2 cong chung va Hop dong chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat so: 15883 ngay 23/11/2018 giua ba Nguyen Thi DI vdi ba Nguyen Thi Thanh T1 do Van phong cong chung Nguyen Thi G cong chung.
A 9
-
4. An phi dan sir phuc tham:
9
Ba Phan Kim H4 la ngudi cao tuoi, co don xin mien an phi nen khong phai chiu an phi dan sir phuc tham;
/\ r y r
Ong Vuong Huy P la ngudi ke thua quyen, nghia vu to tung cua bi don r y y 9
phai chiu so tien 300.000d (ba tram nghin dong) an phi dan sir phuc tham. Diroc khau trir vao so tien 300.000d (ba tram nghin dong) tarn ung an phi dan sir phuc tham da nop theo Bien lai thu tarn ung an phi so: 0000029 ngay 13/12/2023 cua Cue thi hanh an dan sir tinh Binh Duong.
-
5. Cac quyet dinh khac cua Ban an so tham khong co khang cao, khong bi khang nghi co hieu lire phap luat ke tu ngay het thdi han khang cao, khang nghi.
9 9
-
6. Ban an phuc tham cd hieu lire phap luat ke tu ngay tuyen an.
N(ri nhan:
-
- Toa an nhan dan toi cao;
-
- VKSND cap cao tai TP.HCM;
-
- TAND tinh Binh Duong;
-
- VKSND tinh Binh Duong;
-
- Cue THADS tinh Binh Duong; -DS;
-
- Luu VP. HS. DTTB.
TM. HOI DONG XET XtT PHUC THAM THAM PHAN - CHU TOA PHIEN TOA
Nguyen Van Khirong
Bản án số 18/2024/HNGĐ-PT ngày 04/06/2024 của TAND cấp cao tại TP Hồ Chí Minh về tranh chấp về chia tài sản khi ly hôn
- Số bản án: 18/2024/HNGĐ-PT
- Quan hệ pháp luật: Tranh chấp về chia tài sản khi ly hôn
- Cấp xét xử: Phúc thẩm
- Ngày ban hành: 04/06/2024
- Loại vụ/việc: Hôn nhân và gia đình
- Tòa án xét xử: TAND cấp cao tại TP Hồ Chí Minh
- Áp dụng án lệ: Đang cập nhật
- Đính chính: Đang cập nhật
- Thông tin về vụ/việc: Bà Phan Kim H kiện Ông Vương Anh D “V/v ly hôn và chia tài sản khi ly hôn”.